Bare Naked Bakery — Restaurant in Town of Oyster Bay

One of our guests has celiac disease, another has a severe nut allergy, and many are vegan. This prompted us to look for a bakery that could accommodate all of those needs in one cake. We were on the hunt for a bakery that would taste good to everyone including the pickiest eaters. We ordered three half sheet cakes, one of which arrived in the wrong flavor. I only mention this because it was still so delicious and happened to go really well with the homemade apple topping we made for the top. We had ordered vanilla with custard and received a spice cake. The only thing that was a bummer about this was not knowing which flavor it was for sure (because we would totally order it again LOL).

All of our guests LOVED the cakes! They continued to feed our family for several days after the event , continuing to taste fresh. I'm sure Bare Naked became most people's go-to bakery overnight. My partner and I aren't the biggest fans of Gluten-free foods but can appreciate a good bake no matter what. These were by far some of - if not, theee best cakes we ever had! If you're someone considering ordering from this bakery for one or more of your guests, we'd highly recommend getting all of your cake from here. There was truly no need to add on another vendor! We're glad we took the chance and got all three cakes from here.

The process of selecting and ordering the cakes was quick (in-person) and the employees there show a lot of joy and pride in what they do. The bakery was kind enough to send over two free cannoli dip trays which were also beloved by all guests and not just those...

This bakery was a pleasant surprise the day before Easter. I stopped by for some gluten free and vegan desserts for the holiday and the place was empty. As seen in the pic we purchased a good assortment of gluten free and some vegan desserts. The store was filled with fresh out of the oven baked goods. I'm not sure if this was due to the holiday or it always is like that but I was surprised how fresh everything was. Specifically, the canollis we're very good- not vegan due to the cheese filing. The napoleans were vegan. I was disappointed when questioning what the "cream" ingredients were in the vegan items, and I couldn't get a very specific ingredient list. Also the bakery is nut free so some items don't have the authentic almond taste. The linzer tarts we're very good, and I was overall very pleased....

I have ordered a cake in August 2021 and it was delicious; a strawberry shortcake. Since it was so good, we ordered a cake in November 2021. The order, the SAME as before, the cake batter was completely different, the texture was very weird and in brown color. We weren’t able to give this cake to our friends. I decided to call the day after to ask what happened and have been patiently waiting for the manager to return my call. I have been calling everyday since (3 days) and they are only giving me excuses on why the manager can’t return my calls. I have asked everyone in there why this time the cake is different and nobody know anything. As other reviewers mentioned before, they need to improve in QA and in customer service. At this point I think they prefer a bad review instead of a decent...