Manetto Hill Plaza — Local services in Town of Oyster Bay

Manetto Hill Plaza is a solid and convenient local shopping center that I visit frequently. It offers a practical mix of shops and services, and it’s located right in the heart of Plainview, which makes it incredibly accessible for quick errands or a casual stop.

One of the most notable additions to the plaza is the new Amazon Fresh store. It’s a great upgrade for the area—modern, clean, and well-organized. Whether you’re there for groceries, returns, or just to grab something prepared, the store adds real value to the plaza and has become a regular part of my routine.

Unfortunately, not all experiences here have been positive. I was a long-time patient at Meadowbrook Dentistry, located in the same plaza. After six years of good service, things took a turn under the new manager. I encountered poor customer service, lack of follow-up, and a complete absence of accountability. Despite my patience and efforts to be understanding, the dentist never intervened, and the owner never called to address the issue. It was disappointing to see a once-reliable office lose its professionalism.

That said, the plaza overall remains a useful and well-maintained spot. Its mix of everyday essentials and recent upgrades like Amazon Fresh make it a dependable stop for...

Got to Fairway around 9PM for some items to bring back my hotel and the service was actually worse than the layout of the store. 6 different people with 6 different opinions on where to find Splenda. I walked the entire store for 30 minutes until the guy sweeping the floor took me to the shelf in the isle that no one even mentioned. Not funny to make a handicapped person that just buried his father exhaust himself for something that should have taken 2...

Many of the stores in this strip mall have closed or are in the process of closing since the Pandemic. Fairway and Dirty Burger are already closed. Pet Value is in the process of closing. I will try to update with new info when I have it. I recommend calling to make sure a store is open...