Solomons Jewelers — Local services in Town of Oyster Bay

I’ve been to the store only twice, but Robert is the only jeweler I trust. 30 years ago he reset my solitaire engagement into a wave setting that is beautiful. Neither the center diamond nor the 4 side diamonds have ever come loose. I’ve always wanted an emerald cut diamond with baguettes. I was with a friend at a pawn shop and bought a ring the the diamond, fiur baguettes and diamond chips all around the band. I called and made an appointment with Robert to reset the diamonds. I brought it it him (I live in South Jersey) and told him what Setting I would like. He reset the center diamond with one baguette on each side in a platinum setting. I received it in the mail about a week later. It is absolutely beautiful. He then used the other two baguettes to make the matching wedding band (also in platinum). Received quickly also. They are beautiful and are exactly what I envisioned. After I get settled in Florida, I am planning on filling my jewelry box. Solomon’s Jewelers is where I will be calling to purchase the jewelry pieces I...

Changing a watch battery is fairly simple. It's the kind of thing most handy people will want to do themselves. I live nearby and called to find out how much a watch battery costs. I had already opened the watch and was ready to replace it. They quoted me $10 for something that costs less than $2. I understand they need to make a profit but that's just ridiculous. Why would you want to overcharge by so much on such a little item? Would it not be better to build a little customer relationship in hopes they come back for bigger and more expensive needs? Why would I go here for anything else if I know they overcharge by so much? Oh well...

PS. If you need a watch battery in the area, check out Kim's Watches. They sold me one for $3. I am not affiliated in any way with that store. Just trying to pass on good...

Excellent store, huge selection of quality jewelry and top-notch customer care.

The helpful staff here, notably Rob on my visit, helped me choose an engagement ring setting and stones that complemented a family heirloom stone that I wanted to include in the ring. Their suggestions were invaluable and the final result was stunning.

The ring was of very high quality with nice touches in the setting that helped the heirloom stone really “pop”.

I live out of state but consider Solomon to be “my” jewelry store. On my next visit to Long Island I’ll be shopping there for...