Gyrolicious — Restaurant in Town of Oyster Bay

Really good food. We visited recently and ordered an appetizer, 2 entrées and some sides. Everything was really good. Probably the best I've had in the area. Literally can't find any fault with the quality of their food whatsoever.

Unfortunately the service really sucked. Our waiter made us feel lik like an inconvenience the entire time. He was unengaged and more involved with whatever was going on with his phone the entire time. He was out of sight throughout most of our meal, hanging out in a service area behind a wall. There were no other servers in the establishment when we visited.

The restaurant was nearly empty when we arrived, just 4 tables, all with their meals on the table. We had to ask repeatedly for things like condiments and water. We will return because of the food, but this is not a place we would bring guests to because of the service issues.

Prices were quite reasonable however a side of lemon potatoes was $5 and for that we received 4 potato slices, not even a...

REVISED REVIEW

Had to bump this place up to the 5 stars it deserves. The first time I went here, the food was good, but I felt it could be better. This last time I went, the food was absolutely amazing.

The gyros are super hearty. They're slightly more money than other places, but literally double the size. Fantastic value right there. The stuffed grape leaves were very fresh and tasty. And the babaganoush I got this time was how I expected it, and how they described it. It had a great roasty and smoky flavor with perfect texture.

I also have to add that the service is high quality. My order was perfect, and nothing was out of place. The woman behind the counter was friendly and courteous, really made me feel welcomed.

100% my new gyro spot. I'll recommend this place...

This is the most delicious home-made Greek food I’ve ever had. I ordered the moussaka and it came with the most delicious salad accompanied by tasty lemon potatoes. The moussaka was filled with tender beef, potatoes and eggplant which with the filo-dog was nothing short of good.The tzatziki sauce was incredible! It was not over-powering with citrus which I very much appreciated. My husband had the chicken souvlaki which was tender and well-seasoned. We ended the night with rice pudding which was sooo rich and creamy. I loved that it wasn’t too sweet. The only downside to the place is service. It’s too slow. Perhaps getting another waiter/ waitress would be helpful as it took very long for every transaction to the table. All in all, awesome place and would...