16 Handles — Restaurant in Town of Oyster Bay

Best froyo because it’s self-serve & priced by wt. Definitely recommend a yogurt-to-toppings ratio of 1:4 at MOST. Trust. Bc the froyo is a weird consistency (a tad watery/icy instead of smooth) it’s best as just a base for the toppings rather than the main. By the time you get home it’ll be like a sticky sweet soup.

They have the staples & rotate flavors a lot, including dairy-free ice cream & twist flavors. They stay on top of trends and seasons (recently mango lassi & dubai chocolate, and fruity flavors for summer).

I like their graham cracker, vanilla, and original tart froyo flavors. For toppings: brownie bites, cheesecake bites, cookie dough bites, graham cracker crumbs, oreos, hazelnut crunch, chopped kitkat, hot fudge, whipped cream. (The small chewy/doughy ones go better than hard or big ones like M&Ms, cookies, & cookie dough balls.) If you put Oreos/graham on top and then hot fudge, it creates a nice layer to dig into!

Small sized cup is usually enough. It’s $5-13 depending on how much you pack it. They sometimes have deals where you can fill up your cup for $5/$7. I’ve never seen anyone get their shakes or açaí bowls but the DO cookie dough they...

We went tonight at 7pm with our 6 year old son and 18 month old daughter. My son wanted to sample a couple flavors because he didn't know what he wanted. My husband went up to the register where there were 2 young women working, one was chowing down on pizza and neither one acknowledged him when he walked up to counter. He politely asked for a sample cup and was told "no samples allowed" He asked why and was not given an answer. He told them it is for our 6 year old to try a couple of flavors so that way we don't fill a bowl up, pay for it and have him not like it. He was again told "no samples allowed." My husband then said "So you are willing to lose paying customers because you can't give out a sample cup?" The reponse from the girls behind the counter were "we don't care." We have been to other froyo places and have had no issues sampling, a lot of places encourage it, they leave the sample cups out...NOT here! Not only could we not get a sample but the customer service was horrendous. We walked out and went to another Froyo place, TCBY, that let my son try as many flavors...

Out of all the 16 handles locations I've been to (probably like 5 different ones) this one was the best! They had ask the fresh fruits toppings I like, the place was clean, and the frozen yogurt itself tasted better. I know it makes no sense cause they're all supposed to be exactly the same frozen yogurt, but both my wife and myself agreed that this location had a better texture than the others we've had, it was much more creamy here, more like ice cream texture, the other places were more icy. Not sure if there is an outside factor that caused it, maybe the outside temperature, maybe the time of day. I don't know why, but it was just better here. Could be a fluke, as it was the only time I've been to...