Pizzaiolo Express — Restaurant in Town of Oyster Bay

UPDATE: This is terrible. I just got the news that Pietro actually passed away. He was always such a generous and kind guy. My condolences go out to his family.

I don't know where to begin; the desserts, the pizza, the stuffed chicken Parmesan - it's all so delicious. Pietro and his team do their very best in an effort to deliver quality and professionalism - never once have they failed in bringing exactly that. They're all so hard-working and are always (extreme understatement) generous as far as portions go. Thank you Pietro, thank you to your team, and thank you for such...

Restaurant was clean and had enough space/seating available. Staff was friendly and the service was fast. Hawaiian slice had good flavor, but being a deep dish crust, it felt like too much dough for it. Sicilian slice was thick as it should be but needed some more sauce. Vodka grandma slice tasted a bit dry and the crust was thicker compared to other pizzerias. Regular grandma slice had great flavor but needed some more sauce throughout each slice. White slice was loaded with a very thick layer of cheese with a good thin crust, but some complained of it...

My wife and I just flew in for a wedding and staying locally. It was getting late and we wanted to get some food and we stumbled over this gem of a pizza place! We tried some different types of their pizza and it was delicious ! We loved the thin crust on the cheese pizza ! The Sicilian with sausage was fantastic and my wife loved the chicken with broccoli! The chicken Marcela was out of this world! The staff was super friendly! We would come back over and over if we lived here. I'm a pizza snob and I don't say lightly that I highly recommend Mama Mias...