HTML SitemapExplore

Siena's Pizza — Restaurant in Town of Thompson

Name
Siena's Pizza
Description
Homey restaurant whipping up pizzas & other Italian specialties in a straightforward space.
Nearby attractions
Dome 2030 and Arcade
321 E Broadway Suit 8, Monticello, NY 12701
Nearby restaurants
Upside Craft Burger & Kosher Bar
321 E Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701
Casa Cava
321 E Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701
Simply Sushi LLC
343 E Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701
Taam Eden Bakery
321 E Broadway Suite 9, Monticello, NY 12701
J's Soft Serve
366 E Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701, United States
Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard
287 E Broadway #3, Monticello, NY 12701
LA FONDITA MEXICANA
371 E Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701
Fialkoff's Kosher Pizza
250 E Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701
Yanni's Gyro Express
28 Pleasant St, Monticello, NY 12701
Miss Monticello Diner
405 Broadway #1, Monticello, NY 12701
Nearby hotels
Upstate Inn Monticello
12 Jones St, Monticello, NY 12701
Super 8 by Wyndham Monticello
290 E Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701
Inn At Monticello
392 Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701
Related posts
Keywords
Siena's Pizza tourism.Siena's Pizza hotels.Siena's Pizza bed and breakfast. flights to Siena's Pizza.Siena's Pizza attractions.Siena's Pizza restaurants.Siena's Pizza travel.Siena's Pizza travel guide.Siena's Pizza travel blog.Siena's Pizza pictures.Siena's Pizza photos.Siena's Pizza travel tips.Siena's Pizza maps.Siena's Pizza things to do.
Siena's Pizza things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Siena's Pizza
United StatesNew YorkTown of ThompsonSiena's Pizza

Basic Info

Siena's Pizza

321 Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701
3.8(195)$$$$
order
Order
delivery
Save
spot

Ratings & Description

Info

Homey restaurant whipping up pizzas & other Italian specialties in a straightforward space.

attractions: Dome 2030 and Arcade, restaurants: Upside Craft Burger & Kosher Bar, Casa Cava, Simply Sushi LLC, Taam Eden Bakery, J's Soft Serve, Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard, LA FONDITA MEXICANA, Fialkoff's Kosher Pizza, Yanni's Gyro Express, Miss Monticello Diner
logoLearn more insights from Wanderboat AI.
Phone
(845) 791-7662
Website
sienaspizza.com

Plan your stay

hotel
Pet-friendly Hotels in Town of Thompson
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Affordable Hotels in Town of Thompson
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Trending Stays Worth the Hype in Town of Thompson
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Reviews

Nearby attractions of Siena's Pizza

Dome 2030 and Arcade

Dome 2030 and Arcade

Dome 2030 and Arcade

4.7

(10)

Open 24 hours
Click for details

Things to do nearby

Healing Hugs with Rescue Goats
Healing Hugs with Rescue Goats
Sat, Jan 10 • 12:30 PM
Napanoch, New York, 12458, United States
View details
Adventure Hike with the Herd
Adventure Hike with the Herd
Thu, Jan 8 • 12:00 PM
Napanoch, New York, 12458
View details
Friday Fitness Series Winter 2025 - 2026
Friday Fitness Series Winter 2025 - 2026
Fri, Jan 9 • 10:00 AM
64 Ferndale-Loomis Road, Liberty, NY, United States, New York 12754
View details

Nearby restaurants of Siena's Pizza

Upside Craft Burger & Kosher Bar

Casa Cava

Simply Sushi LLC

Taam Eden Bakery

J's Soft Serve

Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

LA FONDITA MEXICANA

Fialkoff's Kosher Pizza

Yanni's Gyro Express

Miss Monticello Diner

Upside Craft Burger & Kosher Bar

Upside Craft Burger & Kosher Bar

4.8

(117)

Click for details
Casa Cava

Casa Cava

4.5

(87)

Click for details
Simply Sushi LLC

Simply Sushi LLC

4.5

(229)

Click for details
Taam Eden Bakery

Taam Eden Bakery

4.9

(32)

Click for details
Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
Wanderboat LogoWanderboat

Your everyday Al companion for getaway ideas

CompanyAbout Us
InformationAI Trip PlannerSitemap
SocialXInstagramTiktokLinkedin
LegalTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

Get the app

Š 2025 Wanderboat. All rights reserved.

Posts

Your browser does not support the video tag.
sienaspizza_stjohnssienaspizza_stjohns
The Best Pizza in St Johns,Fl ❤️ #SienasPizza #StJohnsFL #LocalEats #SupportLocal #BestPizzaInTown #BestPizzeria #NotYourAveragePizzeria #FreshAndDelicious #WineAndPizza #stjohns
Emanuel PascalEmanuel Pascal
Siena’s Pizza is a small spot, but I really liked the open kitchen setup—you can see them making the pizza, which is a nice touch. I was a little hesitant to order after reading some mixed reviews, but I decided to give it a shot. I placed a phone order for pickup, and the lady on the phone was really sweet and patient, making sure everything was correct. She told me the order would be ready in 25 minutes, and when I arrived after 35 minutes, it was already waiting for me—perfect timing. The prices are reasonable, and the food did not disappoint. The pizza was excellent, definitely one of the best around. I also ordered wings, asking for them well done, and they were cooked perfectly—crispy and flavorful. The cheesesteak, however, was just okay; the bread wasn’t great, which took away from the experience. Overall, I’ll definitely be coming back for the pizza and wings. If you’re in Monticello and craving a solid slice, Siena’s is worth a try!
Sha FaySha Fay
I’m so aggravated I order from Siena’s regularly and recently I’ve been having bad experiences, I didn’t write a review from my past 2 times ordering pizza but my pizza delivery today made me decide to write a review, The last 2 times I ordered pizza from them, It was overcooked on top and undercooked on the bottom, but I let it go because they’re decently priced and it wasn’t so undercooked that it couldn’t be eaten but still. The reason I finally decided to write a review because now I’m irritated due to the fact that my pizza is messed up from it apparently falling in the car of the driver, cheese is stuck to the top of the box and again it’s overcooked, but this time only slightly however, I’m so mad that I am not ordering from them anymore
See more posts
See more posts
hotel
Find your stay

Pet-friendly Hotels in Town of Thompson

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

The Best Pizza in St Johns,Fl ❤️ #SienasPizza #StJohnsFL #LocalEats #SupportLocal #BestPizzaInTown #BestPizzeria #NotYourAveragePizzeria #FreshAndDelicious #WineAndPizza #stjohns
sienaspizza_stjohns

sienaspizza_stjohns

hotel
Find your stay

Affordable Hotels in Town of Thompson

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
Siena’s Pizza is a small spot, but I really liked the open kitchen setup—you can see them making the pizza, which is a nice touch. I was a little hesitant to order after reading some mixed reviews, but I decided to give it a shot. I placed a phone order for pickup, and the lady on the phone was really sweet and patient, making sure everything was correct. She told me the order would be ready in 25 minutes, and when I arrived after 35 minutes, it was already waiting for me—perfect timing. The prices are reasonable, and the food did not disappoint. The pizza was excellent, definitely one of the best around. I also ordered wings, asking for them well done, and they were cooked perfectly—crispy and flavorful. The cheesesteak, however, was just okay; the bread wasn’t great, which took away from the experience. Overall, I’ll definitely be coming back for the pizza and wings. If you’re in Monticello and craving a solid slice, Siena’s is worth a try!
Emanuel Pascal

Emanuel Pascal

hotel
Find your stay

The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

hotel
Find your stay

Trending Stays Worth the Hype in Town of Thompson

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

I’m so aggravated I order from Siena’s regularly and recently I’ve been having bad experiences, I didn’t write a review from my past 2 times ordering pizza but my pizza delivery today made me decide to write a review, The last 2 times I ordered pizza from them, It was overcooked on top and undercooked on the bottom, but I let it go because they’re decently priced and it wasn’t so undercooked that it couldn’t be eaten but still. The reason I finally decided to write a review because now I’m irritated due to the fact that my pizza is messed up from it apparently falling in the car of the driver, cheese is stuck to the top of the box and again it’s overcooked, but this time only slightly however, I’m so mad that I am not ordering from them anymore
Sha Fay

Sha Fay

See more posts
See more posts

Reviews of Siena's Pizza

3.8
(195)
avatar
1.0
4y

Unaccomidating and jumping through pointless hoops! I never had an issue in the past until today.I ordered what I typically order, which is suicide wings (which are mild at best) with a request of lemon pepper sauce on the side.  This combination makes the wings hotter which I prefer. Siena made these wings for me in the past with no issue. I contacted Siennas by phone just to ensure that my order would arrive correctly since it was delivery and there site wouldn't allow me to specify that the 1.50 extra sauce fee was for lemon pepper sauce. Sienas told me they couldn't make my order this way because I did an online order, so I asked them to cancel my online order and I would phone in the order.  They then told me I needed to cancel it myself so I got off the phone with them attempted to do so, but the site wouldn't allow me. I then called them back explained the issue and so they finally canceled my online order so it could be changed to a call in order for delivery.  Ultimately at the very end of the order a gentleman got on the phone told me he could make me lemon pepper wings I explained I wanted the suicidal wings with lemon pepper sauce on the side and I was willing to pay 3xs the 1.50 extra sauce fee. He then told me No...ultimately after all the back and forth I was frustrated and upset which led to canceling my whole order with them. My business went to Giovanni's, they accommodated my sauce needs and received a nice tip. Siena, my advice...try harder with customer service or learn to make...

   Read more
avatar
1.0
6y

This place is gross. 1/2 a star sounds better..

The Food was terrible and the place is nasty The ceiling tiles all through the Resturant are full of black mold. The ceiling vents are blowing fuzz all over the place. Good knows what's growing in there. Im told the pizza is good. Lol

But i still veered from the path of pizza thinking how bad could it be...so I ordered spaghetti and meat sauce before we even sat down inside and my husband was committed to eating there bc he gets take out lunch there during the week and seems to like the pizza. The salad that came before the "meal" was pretty gross..almost watered down.. How do you screw up salad?? But ok. Didn't finish more then two bites of that. I took a spoon full of spaghetti and put it to my face..the smell was horrid..absolutely horrid. I dareingly stuck my tounge out to taste the sauce, it was putrid.and now that taste is lingering. I instantly brought the food up to the counter and asked the girl to remove this from our bill and i told her the food was terrible...no one apologized for the horrible experience and my husband powered through his meal because his was ok while i just observed.. I wouldn't have wanted anything in place of my meal but no one even offered me something else in its place.

Absolutly terrible customer service, the food and atmosphere were horrid. I will NEVER eat here again and id advise others too be cautious unless your just getting pizza. .but i...

   Read more
avatar
1.0
6y

We’re long time customer and although the wait for delivery is sometimes longer the pizza is delicious. Tonight I ordered and was told 1- 1 1/2 hours for delivery. Okay, my choice. They usually get here much sooner. Took about 1 1/4 hour. Delivery guy is always just so nice. Opened pizzas and one of them was wrong. Should be plain but got pepperoni. Kids won’t eat it. Called and was told they’d have another one here in half an hour and take back the pepperoni. Take it back??? To do what with??? Can’t sell it! 40 minutes go by, no pizza. I call and I’m upset, tell them kids are waiting. She says they’re waiting for a driver. I say, you’re kidding me! It’s going to be 2 hours since I placed my order. She very snotily asks, so you want the pizza or not?!? I say yes! The kids are hungry! They did nothing to accommodate us. Not even an apology. How about, I’m very sorry! The driver comes back and he’s apologizing and saying he’ll talk to the manager and he wouldn’t take the wrong pizza back. Smart guy. They lost a long time customer. We order almost every Friday and with tip spend 50 bucks each time. My son in law called to complain and after another horrific experience on the phone they consent to a refund. I’ll keep a watch for it. Get better counter people! Giovanni and Colosseo have great pizza too. Just sayin’ Update: yeah, no...

   Read more
Page 1 of 7
Previous
Next