HobNob Pizza — Restaurant in Upper Arlington

The pizza is the best in the area, but the service is a nightmare. They need to hire someone that knows how to run a pizza shop and communicate effectively with customers. Almost all of the staff has a deer-in-headlights look at every question. Accurate pickup times would be helpful. And getting a beer next door at Old Bag while waiting is a joke. They move even slower

10/17/23 UPDATE: I have updated my scores above and would like to say that the service improved dramatically in the weeks following my review last year. When you order online, you get a text when your pizza is going into the oven and unlike back then, it's ready when i get there. And i will reiterate, the pizza...

I’ve been here handful of times now and every single experience has been great. No joke, one of the best NY pies in the city. Not a huge tavern style fan but I’ve had it and it’s on par with Tommy’s/Iaconos. Tried the cauliflower crust tonight (someone else ordered it) and it was by far the best I’ve had. Also ordered the Caesar salad and it was fantastic. Fresh, great croutons and the Caesar dressing was the bomb. If it’s not a house dressing, I’d like to know what it is and where I can get it.

So stoked to have such a quality...

Rumor has it the owner baked versions of their crust for 90 days until they got it right. Now I easily could have just started that soon to be urban legend BUT I did hear it and it tastes like that story could be true! This place is a must if you consider urself a pizza connoisseur. I would compare their Midwest crust to Tommy’s as their New York style crust is thicker. It’s good! Every bit as good as Tommy’s is being said as...