The bagel stands alone! With so many "bagel" places being nothing more than a roll with a hole in the middle and some toppings, Fill A Bagel actually makes a true bagel, crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside with a normal amount of toppings; I'll typically get a loose bagel or two just to enjoy as a snack. That's not to say you won't be unhappy with a sandwich - the sausage, egg, and cheese is loaded with fillings, putting so many other places in the area to shame. The staff is courteous and extremely efficient, getting orders in and out fast despite the tight quarters of the shop. Quality has been consistent since discovering this place back in 2019 when we moved into the area. I'm so glad to be able to support such an outstanding...
Read moreEDIT: dropping to three stars. as others have mentioned, prices have gotten higher while bagels have gotten smaller. the last two times I went, the everything bagels were very skimpy on the seasoning as well. Still generous with the cream cheese but what's the point if the bagel is small and bland? Won't be going back again soon.
ORIGINAL REVIEW: Pretty good standalone bagels and always a good amount of cream cheese. I tried one of the overpriced bagel sandwiches (that they don't let you customize at all) and the egg was atrocious. If you're getting from here, stick to bagels and don't waste your money on the sandwiches. Sometimes the workers can have a bad attitude. I always strive to be polite and...
Read moreAfter getting my order wrong more times than getting right. I’ve finally decided to never return. Not sure if they can’t understand normal thinking or if no one there can understand English but it seems insane to me that they can’t figure out how to put both butter AND cream cheese on a bagel. This is the only bagel shop I have ever been to where grown adults can’t seem to follow the most simple instructions. It’s infuriating and I would impress on anyone planning to visit to keep driving to the dunkin for bagels. They will at least get your order correct. If I could give zero...
Read more