Learn more insights from Wanderboat AI.
Get Air Pickerington
4.1
(376)
A & J Wingburger
4.6
(231)
Squeek's Bar and Grill
4.5
(176)
Rick's Freshmade Cafe and Catering
4.8
(85)
$$
Indian Spice Restaurant and Bar
4.7
(231)
$$
I get a Pizza here almost once a week, and trust me.. it’s better than the 4-5 star reviews say it is.
Best Pizza in the MidWest!
If you are worried about what the few bad reviews, I can tell you some of what they are saying is accurate.
No scams here though. The owner basically does all the prep work and day to day operations solo. As of the date of this review, I can say that the hours of operation do vary which can be problematic for people ordering online.
He is a family man working his butt off offering a product that few places could duplicate even with a season staff at hand… and he is just one man!
The consistency is on point when he is opened for Business and I have yet to have a bad meal there well into year of going.
With that all being said, I highly recommend you order in person if it is...
Read more
Used to tell my friends “pizza is pizza, there’s no bad pizza” but I was wrong.. this was the most unappetizing pizza I’ve ever had. Everything was closed so had to order here. Got their buffalo chicken pizza and it was straight garbage.. (I usually don’t leave bad reviews but this I had no other choice) the pizza was so greasy🤮🤮. And the chicken was not fully cooked. The pizza felt like it was frozen pizza that was microwaved. (It could be just one of those days but I’m not convinced with this place. (The atmosphere and service was cool tho, just the food was not).. not sure if I’m be going back anytime soon. Let’s see...
Read more
Have been living in Pickerington since 1987 and have had every pizza that has come along. Have been disappointed in a lot of the latest ones. Have driven by this place many times and never really thought that it was the most inviting place to go. I have to say that it this is one of the best pizzas I have had in quite a while. I had the power house, and what I was impressed with was the crust, almost like a really good bread. Tonight was the first time I have ever had it and will definitely go back again. Being a small business owner myself in Pickerington, I highly...
Read more
