Bagelwich Bagel Bakery — Restaurant in West Caldwell

Best bagels around ! A real bagel bakery. Bottled beverages available, coffee is only so-so, about 10 different bagel choices available, several choices of cream cheese, Under previous manager/owner? and staff, prices were better and serving of cream cheese was generous, not so now. My rating based solely on quality of the bagel; otherwise it's a 3 star. Update: Bagels still top notch. Today they botched my single bagel order but no big deal. Lots of customers on Sunday morning and staff trying to fill more than one order at the same time. Credit card charge fee still a mickey mouse annoyance. Will continue...

I have been going to the bagel which in Verona my entire life and it’s a great spot . I moved to Caldwell and been going to that one which is such a headache . Not to sound rude but I have a problem every time I order there . They never remember my order - or if I order 30 min in advance and go to pick up they never even started my order . Every single time I have ordered from the store in Caldwell these workers seem incompetent. I have nothing but good things to say about the workers and the Verona store but unfortunately it’s night and day compared...

Tried this local spot out today for the first time. Does good business it was a busy Saturday morning. I thought they had really good prices. We ordered 5 bagels and it took a few minutes to come out but nothing crazy. They were working hard there. I’d say it’s an average bagel place. It wasnt bad but nothing special. I’m sure there’s other places that are worse and I know there’s better bagels out there. Typical bagel shop Inside. Large menu lots to...