NYPD Pizza Winter Park — Restaurant in Winter Park

Meal was delivered, so expected meal to be not piping hot

I’ll start off by saying that this restaurant had a lot to live up to as it replaced Frank’s which was fantastic.

The order: Large garlic knots, mozzarella sticks, half meat lover’s/half cheese pie

Garlic Knots - by far the star of what we ordered. Slightly doughy on the inside. Pulled apart with a stretch. The fresh garlic was perfect. Marinara was delicious.

Mozzarella sticks - cold (yes, got it delivered, but the garlic knots were still warm so..who knows). My biggest concern is that it tasted like they were on a sheet/surface that must have been made with zeppoles, as there was cinnamon all over them. Kind of ruined the taste for me.

Pizza - crust was one of the best I’ve had in a long time (again, the pizza was still warm when it got to us, just the mozzarella sticks were cold). The toppings were top notch and delicious. The sauce though, was just a little light. I don’t want a pizza that gets soggy from the sauce, but I should be able to taste it in every bite.

Overall, it wasn’t bad, but it wasn’t great either. We will probably give them another try in the next couple of months to see if this is just new location issues.

I can’t write to the service or atmosphere as we had the...

Authentic New York slice right here in Winter Park on university near goldenrod. The cheese is the star—stretchy, flavorful, and not oily—and the crust is thin, foldable, and perfectly crisp with that real NYC feel. The buffalo chicken pizza is ridiculous (in the best way): tons of flavor and real buffalo heat without overpowering. Staff was genuinely friendly from the second I walked in and the place was spotless—you can tell they take pride in it. If you’ve been searching for legit New York–style pizza, this is it y’all. Do yourself a favor and try it for...

I stopped by NYPD and was seriously impressed! The pizza was perfectly baked crispy on the outside, soft and chewy inside with just the right amount of sauce and cheese. You can really taste the quality of the ingredients. The staff were super friendly and made me feel welcome right away. The place has a cozy vibe, and everything came out fresh and hot i felt like i was in nyc. I especially recommend the wings it’s a must-try!

If you’re a pizza lover looking for great flavor and great service, this is the place. I’ll definitely be coming...