Wyckoff Delicatessen — Restaurant in Wyckoff

Didn't rate all 5 stars because I have been there 4 times, but plan to return. I ordered different foods each time. The soups are delicious, some have a little kick. The fresh salads are loaded, love the butternut salad. The chicken pot pies are filling, tasty and the crust is just right. Not too heavy yet substantial enough to match the chicken and vegetables. Great for after skiing. The spinach quiche is also very good. I got a small one and plan to get a large one. Just right amt of egg and cheese to be able to taste both without overpowering the spinach. Next trip will try the deli sandwiches. If you like butter on your buttered roll order one here. They are generous to a fault. Scrape some off and save it for another roll. The staff are pleasant and business like. Returned and tried new salads and sandwiches. Tasty is the right word. They add just the right ingredient to make it special. Creative. I think to taste it is to really like it. I think they deserve 5 stars, not only for good food but for caring about what taste...

I've had good experiences and bad experiences but I won't be going back. I ordered a platter of sandwiches for Easter. I was taking to someone's home. I picked them up Easter morning so that they would be fresh. At least that's what I thought. The bread was stale. The roast beef smelled like fish. Nothing was fresh besides that. I was embarrassed to bring it to the host , so it went in the garbage. I called them wyckoff deli continuously, because I can't call during the day. So I called after 6 hoping I could leave a message. I wasn't able to , so I did send an email, and I asked for a refund, they completely ignored me. Therefore, they're getting this review. It's bad business, I've went there for years. I've gotten bad things before and they did give me a discount for next time. It was one other time, but now this time they completely ignored me. I don't want the discount because I won't be going back. I deserve the refund. Service is getting...

This deli has a variety of fresh made sandwiches. They also have pasta salads, soups & a variety of snack items - fresh made cookies, jello, tapioca, tossed salads, potato chips, pre-packaged baked Entenmann's, Hostess treats and candy. There are also pre-packaged frozen pasta, soups, sauces in case you don't want to cook dinner. Of course, you have your pick of drink items. Bottom line - sandwiches are freshly cut & made to order. Its the best sandwich shop in town. They will make it just like you want it. Love their California Club with bacon & horseradish mayo. Never had one like it before. You won't be disappointed....