Cape Cod Creamery — Restaurant in Yarmouth

Cape Cod Creamery is a must-stop if you’re in the area! The ice cream is incredibly creamy and flavorful, with fun Cape-inspired names like “Monomoy Mud Pie” and “Pleasant-Bay Peanut Butter.” The variety is impressive, and you can see all the flavors beautifully displayed inside the case. We loved how many unique combinations they offered, and everything tasted homemade and fresh.

When we arrived, there was no line, which was perfect for our group. But by the time we sat down with our ice cream, a line had already started forming—clearly a local favorite! I ordered a large dish with 3 scoops, and it was more than enough to satisfy my sweet tooth. My son went with a waffle cone filled with Oreo ice cream. The only bummer was the cone had a large hole in the bottom, and the ice cream started dripping pretty fast. We could have asked for a bowl, but he decided to tackle it as a challenge—and finished it like a champ, eating from...

Like many of the negative reviews...this is about a homemade ice cream joint running out of flavors.

...It shouldn't happen.

I drove here for one purpose...peach ice cream, which is difficult to find. Especially, apparently, at the Cape Cod Creamery on a Friday night. I specifically went to the Yarmouth location because it's only open Friday and Saturday, and I figured they would be fully stocked for the first day of their two day weekend. But...no.

I mean, come on...running out of product on night one? No excuse is good.

A first impression will often be the only impression in food service. Penguins is a couple miles down the road, and is slow but delicious. They don't have peach either, but at least they don't advertise on a website that they do for you to arrive and be disappointed.

Do better. For someone else though, 'cause you...

(last visit 2016) Holy Cow (get it?), amazing ice cream, probably the best I've had. Make sure you get some strawberry and chocolate, might be "standard" flavors but they're crazy good. I really liked the peach and blueberry too, I think the fruit flavors are the real winners, wish I had tried em all. Get some pints/quarts for those late cravings, you will regret it if you don't. Staff was very nice and they all had strong biceps from all the scooping. Lines can be long but they move surprisingly fast, well worth any wait; just don't get too small a portion. A lot of local groceries stock their products too which is great, but best to get it from the source if you can. Only down side is once you've had their stuff, other places feel like a let-down...