Bayside Milk Farm — Attraction in New York

I used to love this place but unfortunately i have to rate them poorly. There's a few workers that are great but every-time I go in and there's a few pieces of salmon (walnut topped) I know there from the previous day. I specifically asked the deli worker (three times) if it was todays salmon or from yesterday. He assured me it was todays, however they never make todays with only 5 pieces on a dish. So of course i fell for it, paid $15 and left. Got to the car and the salmon is ice cold and dry (indicating it's not from today). There's typically a hint of heat to it if it's made the same day even after sitting in the cooler (the fresh salmon comes out closer to 10-11ish). I would have purchased something else had he been honest with me about the dish.

I decided to Go back in and talk to the manager. The lady was not apologetic she took the dish tossed in trash told the cashier give her $15 back and walked away. Not very good customer service but honestly if I'm going to pay $15 for a piece of salmon that your worker ensured me was fresh then it better be fresh.

It's hit or miss here. When the salmon is fresh it's amazing but day old is typically dry and not worth it....

On behalf of The Center for the Women of New York, I want to extend a sincere thank you to Bayside Milk Farms for their generous donation to our Taste of the World at Fort Totten gala.

As a valued local market, they provided hearty veggies and homestyle meatballs. The vegetables were prepared in a rich, savory sauce that gave them a comforting, slow-cooked flavor, and the meatballs were tender and well-seasoned. Our guests appreciated the classic, home-style preparation.

It is because of supportive local businesses like Bayside Milk Farms that we are able to raise important funds for our mission of supporting women in the New York community. Their willingness to contribute to a local cause shows their deep care for the neighborhood, and it is exactly why I make a point to support community-minded businesses like theirs.

We highly recommend Bayside Milk Farms for their generosity and commitment to the community. Thank you for being a wonderful partner and for helping us make...

I have been using Bayside milk farm for 40 or more years. They have quality food. The amount of food you get when ordering catering is amazing. Their gift baskets are incredible. I recently purchased the fruit & nut basket to bring to a close friend. They wanted to open it while I was there. It just kept on going. They kept saying wow when is it going to stop. I needed help bringing it into the house because it was soooo heavy. I’ve ordered gift baskets from other places and stopped because the quality cannot compare to bayside milk farm. I’ll only order from bayside milk farm. Their catering, Heros, wraps, hot food are all delicious and you’ll always have more than enough food. Cannot say enough good things about...