The Pie Hole — Local services in Vancouver

the fat elvis pie was exquisite ! the whipped cream was thick and creamy had a rich peanut buttery taste, with a nice sprinkle of crunchy nuts on top. the banana and peanut butter combination was LETHALLLLL. there was a thick fudgy chocolate layer on the bottom that balanced the sweet banana cream — although the pie slice was very large and all the sweetness got a tad sickening at the end. the crust was perfectly crumbly and super addicting though, it’s always my favourite part.

the raspberry pie was a nice treat as well, i loved how buttery the crust was. i’m not a huge fan of raspberry, but this filling was tart, smooth, and light compared to the fat elvis. i also loved it paired with the refreshing ice cream. however, i asked them to heat it up and it wasn’t really warm when i got it, more like room temperature.

all the cookies are SUPER massive too. i had the s’mores cookie, which was basically a chocolate cookie with two marshalllows, a graham cracker, and a hersheys chocolate in the center. the chocolate cookie base is thick and chewy (the perfect cookie texture), and it reminded me of a crumbl cookie in the way that it was sugary all around. i didn’t have it heated up so that may have affected my experience a bit, but i found that the cookie was good but nothing super special, although i did enjoy the marshmallow.

the place has a really cool navy diner retro vibe and smells super yummy because of all the pies. the enormous selection in the pie display may actually be torture for indecisive people...

This place is high on our treat list! My partner and I have "date night" once or twice a week. All the usual things a couple would do on a special night, including a special dessert are included in date night. Our favourite treats from here:

Raspberry Cream Crumble pie - a classic! This is what they are known for. I've you've never been to the pie hole, this is the one to get.

Colleen's Mistake pie - This one you can almost share with two people (maybe the mistake has something to do with that). Colleen, if you are listening, let me give you some advice: you learn from your mistakes, make some more.

Black Forest Cream Pie - So my partner and I always tease each other about how much we talk about how good the pie is while we eat it. But for this one, we were still talking about it two days later. I don't think it could be any better, it's the perfect mix of chocolate, cherries, crust, whipped cream. It's perfection in a pie.

Some of the pies are made into stuffed cookies, and those are also really amazing (as of August 2025, I see the Black Forest pie stuffed cookie is being trialed, thank you so much - going to try that tonight). The carrot cake is amazing. The savoury pies are amazing. I've never had anything here that wasn't great.

Run, don't walk. PS - some of the pies make guest experiences month to month and aren't always available. Thank god, I need someone else to exercise...

My experience here was super disappointing today. I placed an order to pick up a blueberry goat cheese pie today at 3:39pm. DoorDash stated that it would take about 30 min to get ready. Within 2 minutes after placing the order I received a notification stating my order was already ready for pick up. I was out and obviously can’t rush there right away to get my pie two minutes right after the order was placed. I got there around 4:20pm. Guess what? My pie is not there anymore. The staffs let me know that it’s been sitting on the counter and must have been picked up by the last delivery courier as he probably didn’t look and just took everything there.

No big deal I would think. Just give me another one right? They were completely out of the fresh one. They only have the frozen one left.

What frustrated me the most was that the employees kept mentioning that “the pie was here. It was sitting on the counter for a long time.” So was it my fault that the delivery person picked up the wrong order? The store was not busy and there was 3 staffs there. You wouldn’t think about keeping an eye on the stuff on the counter maybe?

It’s unfortunate and the staffs tried to offer other stuff such as a diff flavour of fresh pie or a few small ones. But I still left feeling like I was the one that...