CP McGinty Jewelers — Local services in Cape Girardeau

Edit: after calling the store, they have rectified the issue I had. Thank you for being kind and understanding. Yes it is an inexpensive sterling silver ring but the sentimental value is so much more than its monetary value. Thank you for going beyond to make your customers happy.

Brought my ring there after I lost a pearl from it, and wanted to get a new one put in. This place was highly recommended, the pearl that was replaced is half the size of the original, it cost just as much as the ring did brand new, and it looks ridiculous. It's a pearl and sapphire ring with a gigantic looking sapphire now and this tiny little pearl. I told them exactly what size the original was. This ring has so much sentimental value and I can't wear it now without looking at it with such sadness. I am so disappointed with the repair. My ring is ruined, thank you cp mcginty for ruining something that was so special to me. I would rather have no pearl than have paid for...

I shopped here for my engagement ring and finally found THE ONE. I love the selection, theres so many beautiful rings and they have plenty of on trend rings but also several unique ring options. I love that they work on rings in house and I dont have to wait weeks for my brand new ring to come back in after being resized. I also love that they have affordable options for center stones if your budget isnt quite ready for a diamond. Oh and of course the customer service was awesome! They went out of their way to accommodate me when I came in to buy. All in all, I would highly recommend this place and had an amazing time shopping and...

Went in for a specific type of engagement ring. The salesperson was perfectly kind and attentive. When they went to ask the owner for help, he took over. He was really disinterested in helping us. His eyes were on the door and clearly had no interest in helping us because it did not seem to be a common style they kept. That's understandable. He could have stated that but instead he was just rude and dismissive. We went to Jayson's and they were so helpful and genuinely enthused to find us something non-conventional. Money well spent...