The Lost Toys — Local services in Garfield

Joe at The Lost Toys is an absolute gem! I picked up the Galactus Hasbro Haslab at an unbeatable price during my first visit, and I was blown away by the atmosphere. Joe’s friendly, humorous, and laid-back approach made the experience feel like catching up with an old friend who happens to have the coolest toy collection. Over my few visits, I’ve also scored a Unicron, Doctor Doom, and heard a whole lot of incredible stories that make each trip memorable.

I can’t recommend The Lost Toys enough—it’s a treasure trove for anyone who loves rare, "lost" collectibles. I’m excited to help bring more exposure to Joe’s amazing business because his shop truly deserves a larger space to showcase all these epic finds. If you’re looking for a one-of-a-kind shopping experience that sparks nostalgia and adventure, this is the...

Had the pleasure of stumbling upon this little shop of time jump. My boyfriend and I spent our time looking at the amazing stock and having wonderful conversations with Joe the owner. Shopping here was not just a visit but an experience. The shelves are filled with well priced childhood memories and Joe will even keep an eye out for you if you're interested in something specific. As for us, we left with a nice bag of Transformers ( Beast wars too). In sum, we will definitely return for another visit. It's hard to not want to when Star wars, Power Rangers, Ninja Turtles, G.I. Joes and more are looking for new homes. I highly...

This place is amazing the name alone is awesome and made me want to check it out and I was glad I did very easy to find especially if your from north jersey the selection was amazing with everything from Gi joe transformers to video games and modern figures it’s the perfect selection for any pop culture fan and collector do yourself a favor and visit this awesome store with the...