Benjamin Moore — Local services in Leonia

For anyone going there for Benjamin Moore paint: they really do close at 5pm (as Google says), not 6pm, as the BM website erroneously states. Apparently they’ve had trouble getting BM to update the hours.

I’ve placed a few paint orders through the BM website for in-store pickup. I’ve since learned that there’s only 1 person at this store who can access those orders in their system; however, that person doesn’t arrive until 10-11am. So if your BM email says that your online order will be ready before 10am, well, it won’t. Just go in person if you need it earlier in the day.

I’ve ordered a number of 8oz sample paint pots, both online and in person at the store. One time (from online), they gave me a color I didn’t order instead of the one I did. Another time (in person), they gave me 2 colors that did not match the ones I’d requested. The labels were for the ones that I’d asked for, but the colors were completely wrong. It was a little busy at that time (a Saturday), and I didn’t realize the colors were wrong until a week later. It all worked out in the end, but just FYI so you can keep an eye out. I didn’t approach the store about it as it didn’t really matter in my case, so I’m unable to report how they would’ve responded. All of my (many) quarts and gallons have all been correct, and that’s what...

Absolutely the best hardware store, of the dying breed of neighborhood stores. Extremely helpful, well stocked, very knowledgeable. Have been a customer for 48 years....

Old fashioned hardware store, with helpful staff and they...