Oyster River Market — Local services in Old Saybrook

I've heard their pies are great. Tried to order one online yesterday, went to pick it up just now and they were inexplicably closed, despite the fact that the hours posted by their door would indicate they should be open. I already paid for my pie online. No one is answering the door or the phone. What's going on? I have my email confirmation and everything; why didn't they call me to reschedule my pickup? I'm extremely disappointed.

Edit: will update this once I've received my order. Spoke with management through their Facebook and they were very prompt. As a restaurant manager myself, most of my irritation at the situation comes from not informing me of changes in their schedule. It's important to keep your customers abreast of alterations which could effect them, especially...

What a cute place - Hidden pie gem! So glad we stopped by. Such a cute little bakery, no inside sitting but beautiful water view outside with several Adirondack chairs to sit, eat the pies and enjoy the view. Lovely!

We bought three kinds of pies: tomato pie, key lime, and blueberry/peach mini pie.

I was looking for a peach pie but it was sold out, however, the baker lady offered to make me one for the wait of one hour. Wow! Great service!! Anyway, I have decided to go with the blueberry/peach they already had made and it was the best choice. Best pie EVER, delicious all three of them. My family and I loved it. Can’t...

Drove out to Oyster River for the first time since last year! Very disappointing, when I called I was told they had a variety of pies. Got there mid morning Sunday, one fruit pie and 1 key lime. The lovely young lady said she was new and they ran out if pies Saturday. We drive 40 minutes for pies?????? Was told Thursday is the best day for pies! Will give it one more try. Hopefully when I call next time they will be...