Sayville Antiques — Local services in Town of Islip

Best antique shop on the island! Great finds, great people, great prices, and they dabble in a little bit of everything (buy, selll, auctions, and something for all kinds of collectors). Included pics of some of fav finds (mirrors, steiffs, furniture, taxidermy, trinket boxes, brass mortar, lil vintage glass lamp, cauldrons, vintage perfume bottles, jewelery, vintage book of the dead, candlesticks, & so so so much more. You just never know what...

Phyllis is great! I was worried about having things shipped without being there in person, but everything went really well just as promised. So thank you, Phyllis it’s a pleasure doing business with you and I look forward to much more. She got my items to the UPS store sooner than expected, and I received...

I have been waiting for 2 years for a refund for an item (ring) that I didn’t get. (Envelope was empty). I have been promised, but nothing. I’m very sorry. Many many calls/emails/texts, etc. Last I spoke a check was coming… nothing. Don’t understand. Never had an issue with an auctioneer...