Pezzella’s Pizzeria and Bar — Restaurant in Forster

My first time experiencing this place at the beginning of the month was amazing. All of my expectations were blown out of the water and everything was executed perfectly, unfortunately this seems to not always be the case. Those amazing standards in hospitality and food quality were no where near met tonight, it was as if I had eaten at an entirely different restaurant. The biggest problem with tonight was the flaws in the food and consistency.

The bases used for the pizzas we had were so thin, I couldn’t pick a single slice up. It was like i was eating a crepe with Italian toppings, I had to use a knife and fork just to comfortable put food in my mouth. The base was so thin and soggy, almost like if you had soaked paper in water. I could literally see through this when I held it up. As a result, None of the toppings had stuck to it.

I’m pretty sure at this point you can’t even call it pizza. The two young chefs cooking tonight need to be taken out of the kitchen and retrained because if the owners saw this, and saw the quality of the food they made us tonight I’m sure they would both be fired.

When I expressed my disappointment to the wait staff it was met with defensive and standoffish attitudes and they were not willing to pass my feedback onto the chef to ensure the issues were resolved. I feel sorry for all of the patrons tonight who order pizza and will receive that poorly executed attempt at authentic...

Fawlty Towers redux. Real hit and miss here Booked on line after reading reviews. They told us on arrival - “oh no table available” so we asked for the vacant table booked for 1 hour later. Stuff up no.1.

Delicious entrees, but then waitress came and reminded us the table was booked in 30 mins while still awaiting a beer that never arrived which she ignored. Please, that’s stuff up 2.

30 mins after our entrees and takeaway pizzas flew out the door, our mains finally arrived - and the table next to us was cleared to accommodate the other booking of 5.

Seafood pasta beautiful but for $38 hardly enough spaghetti and seafood for an entree! Kids pizzas x 3 were great but whole experience soured by abrupt staff and expensive Italian wine that was nice was nice but way overpriced.

Recommend takeaway pizza but not dine in on a weekend unless you’re a local - who the staff favoured for service - or they employ a hospitable competent Front of House. $250 for 2 adults and 3 teens deserves...

Great pizza place in Forster! Partner and I came in for a dinner on a busy Wednesday evening. Got a great seat at a table by the windows with a view of the sunset over Wallis Lake.

The food itself was mostly great, we enjoyed the appetiser thoroughly and the margherita pizza we ordered was exceptional. We were a bit let down by the prawn ravioli which we both felt was a bit bland for our liking. Desert itself was also fair but not the most exceptional.

Great selection of drinks from various cocktails to a great variety of beers and wines to choose from. We enjoyed all the cocktails we tried, particularly the basil smash which tasted fresh and crisp!

Service was great overall however a bit slow at times, completely understandable considering how busy it was however!

Overall it was a great experience for us, we will likely return for the pizza however may try a different pasta next time (the gnocchi pesto looked very enticing and perhaps we should have gone for that instead!). Would...