Heeley Artisan — Restaurant in Sheffield

I posted the review below on Tripadvisor after our first visit to the wonderful Plesters. Now, after our second visit I feel I must whole heartedly endorse my comments. Everything spot-on from start to finish. You must give this place a try!

What a fantastic place! We accidentally happened across Plasters whilst out drinking in the Heeley area of Sheffield. Formally, Surf and Turf it is now known by the family name of Plesters. Table for two and a bottle of house white, (which was on offer and very nice) and we ordered a starter and main each at £19 per person. I had Black Pudding with Quail Egg and dressing and my wife had Caribbean Cod Gougons with dressing. This food was so tasty I had to tell the waiter/owner just how good it was! For mains we had Jerk Salmon and Surf and Turf which were equally amazing, full of flavour and very good value. We shared a desert of Chocolate Cheese Cake and fought over every forkful. Two starters, two mains, one desert and two bottles of wine: £63. It’s a husband and wife business and is very, very well organised, neat, clean and tidy. Can’t wait to go back but we’ve told so many people about it we might not get a table! Booking is advised as opening hours are reduced due to covid...

Excellent food, charming restaurant.

We heard about Surf And Turf through a Groupon deal. Parking was fairly straightforward (single yellow line outside and a small car park on a side street 50 yards away). The restaurant itself is very clean and airy with windows that can be opened onto the street - a fairly quiet and attractive part of London Rd. Staff were very welcoming and service was excellent. The food was superb - well balanced flavours and well presented in the case of each of our choices - and although desserts sounded delicious we found we were more than satisfied after two courses. Would certainly visit again and...

Good deal through Groupon, starter and main course. No sirloin staek available for 2 of us so they 'upgraded' us to rib-eye, which was quite grissley but cooked ok. We had the extras, mushrooms and peppercorn sauce, knew we had to pay for this but at £4 for each extra, the quantity of the sauce and mushrooms was tiny, wine was expensive...ok we didn't have to have these but what we thought was going to be a cheap-ish night out turned into an expensive one, seems they are taking advantage of groupon by offering a decent 2 course meal but then charging over the top for drinks and extras left that 'ripped...