New York Pizza of Alexandria — Restaurant in Alexandria

If I could give 0 stars, I would. Waited like 20 mins for 2 wing orders, one garlic parm and one buffalo. Wings were dry, garlic parm wings had no seasoning (plain) and buffalo sauce was watered down and barely applied. Paid 25 dollars, when my fiance asked for a refund they refused and then told her it would be a 30 minute wait. Waited 30 minutes, he came by and said they were fine and literally tore them apart in front of her and told her they were not dry, WHEN THEY WERE. Freshly fried but soggy and dry, how does that work. So he came back and continued to refuse, said he could only refund one order and offered to remake them. Only ended up leaving with 20 dollars out of the 25, that he took from his own wallet because “they have had a lot of refunds recently”. If there is a problem, fix it. As well as that, I got a slice of cheese pizza that they microwaved for so long it became hard. Please do better or...

Was looking to feed 3 hungry kids and 2 adults after a long Saturday of family fun....called New York Pizza and was told they have a Saturday special....one large pizza with one topping for $16 then you get a free large cheese pizza but you can add toppings to your liking.....so the kids got their pizza and the adults got to customize their large pizza...it was amazing..so much cheese and the toppings were fresh...they even sauté the onions...the slices are huge..when we were done the 3 kids had ate half their pizza and the 2 adults had 1 slice over half left....however as we waited for our pizza I noticed they had fresh slices of lasagna and even have 4 pieces of fried fish with fries for $4.99 and even a 4 piece fried chicken meal for $5.99 .....ya can't beat these prices....and it taste amazing....so, give this place a try....you...

I always support local businesses wherever I go. Sometimes, the aesthetics of a place aren't the best, however, I never judge by looks. I judge by the food and service. My experience was dining in.

I had a Caesar salad and a slice of meat lovers. The pizza had a soggy crust, and toppings that looked like they slid off and they tried to reapply.

The salad was fine, however, it had way too much dressing applied. Putting the dressing on the side would easily solve this issue.

Overall, this was a disappointing meal. Especially with such subpar pizza. I feel I'm being generous with a 2 star rating, however, it's a local business, so I think with some improvements to make time, dough consistency, and a few serving changes on dressing, the 3 stars can...