Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop — Restaurant in Asbury Park

Once every few weeks (maybe a month), I have a craving for some Pizza. This time around I was thinking of Roman Style Pizza, but needed more time to decide whether to drive to Mineola NY (Taglio Pizza) or goto something someone recently recommended, Mercato Roman Pizza (Tappan NY). Finally decided to goto De Lorenzo’s Tomato Pie (Robbinsville NJ). The pies as they promise are always thin, crisp and with char. See the attached photos (One Tomato Pie and One Pie with Roasted Peper, Onion and Mushroom).

To work off the Pizza calories, went to the Jersey Shore and walked on the beach. Walked enough to deserve an Ice Cream treat at Milk Sugar Love (Asbury Park, NJ). This is Milk Sugar Love’s second location in NJ (first one is in Jersey City).

If De Lorenzo’s is amongst the top pizzas in NJ, then Milk Sugar Love is amongst the top Ice Cream in NJ. I had a scoop of Guava Cream Cheese and a scoop of Honey Lavendar.

Pizza, beach and ice cream, I am...

So happy to have this new gem in town. Great location and the staff is very welcoming and professional. Lots of really unique offerings- it's obvious that a lot of thought goes into the creations-it's not just the same old same old. You can tell that they use top notch ingredients and that they take pride in their offerings. I tried the matcha cookie ice cream and salted caramel. Both insanely delicious. They also offer really unique toppings. Well priced and really cute place. Tables and a counter as well as grab and go pre-packed pints. Definitely stop in after hitting the beach and/or Galley (it's right next door) I'd post a picture but the ice cream didn't...

Honestly very good ice cream. And I was so excited to see it opened up down the street. I had the malted cookie and my wife had the blueberry crunch. Both were really good.

I just could not possibly justify going to this place ever again. $6 for literally one scoop is absurd. Maybe it makes sense in Jersey city. But we’re only a few miles from Beach Plum in Bradley and Hoffmans in Spring Lake. It’s a bit ridiculous that a brand new ice cream shop, across the street from a Title I high school is charging double (not exaggerating) the price of Hoffman’s, arguably one of the most celebrated ice cream shops in the Northeast and the price leader in the area.

I wish...