Time Square Pizza Downtown
Time Square Pizza Downtown things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Plan your stay
Posts
26 years on this earth and this is hands down the worst quality pizza I have ever had. Food this bad should not exist. It should actually be illegal to serve food this bad. The wings tasted rotten and the garlic knots were like stale bread covered in garlic water. The only thing remotely palatable was the pizza, and after eating a second slice, even that is debatable. The Diet Pepsi was good though, just be prepared to pay 3 dollars for a drink the same size you would get with a McDonald’s kid’s meal. Did you know it was possible to make ranch dressing bland? I didn’t either, but some how this place has managed to do it. I’ve actually had better quality pizza at Chuck-E-Cheese. This business should be rebranded into a comedy club, because the food is so bad it’s actually laughable. I payed twice the price for the same amount of food I’ve gotten essentially anywhere else. Save yourself the money, order Dominos… or a gas station pizza. Either way, you’ll have a better experience and the food will taste better! P.S, I seriously don’t know how this place has such good reviews. I suspect that most of these reviews are fake. Respectfully, this place should legitimately be shut down.
Rami AmerRami Amer
00
First and last time I'm ordering from here. Absolutely the worst food I've had in Asheboro in the 5 years I've been here. Ordered through Door Dash. Arrived cold - not cold like the driver was late, cold like it was taken out of the fridge and not heated. Alfredo sauce was thin, watery, and barely there with no seasoning at all - no salt, pepper, garlic, nothing. Most of the pasta was plain and had obviously not been tossed in the sauce. My dressing request was ignored and my Toscana salad had black olives, banana peppers, onions and tomatoes - literally 2 different salads thrown together and included the STEM OF THE LETTUCE (see below). I had 5 large pieces of cold soggy non toasted bread. When I called the store, I was told the manager is on vacation and that no one is in charge and then they blamed the DoorDash driver for the food being cold. I don't know when the food was ever good here but it is obviously a joke now.
Sheryl McNeillSheryl McNeill
00
Found a piece of wood on the first bite of my pizza, 1inch piece easily, then when confronted the "owner" lies and claims he's out of town and suddenly, he admits its him. Guy thinks he's big and bad to boot, don't worry bud, we'll see who has the last laugh. Edit: forgot to mention that it was "the works" pizza, it was soggy as can be and absolutely bland and disgusting for the single bite i took, the only flavor was from the wood that shouldn't have been there in the first place. Offered a free pizza in return but when told "why would i want your nasty pizza again" he got nasty and rude instead of being reasonable, i'm from NY as well and this place is an absolute disgrace to claim it's NY style or anything close. go to Medo's, they atleast make decent pizza and italian food.
Jason SchwarzJason Schwarz
00
I am from New Jersey and just recently moved down to NC. Where i am from, the italian food is second to none. I was disappointed with the pizza from this place the last time I got food here. It took me a couple months to build up the courage to try it again. Well, I am glad I did. I ordered a stromboli this time around because I have yet to find a place that has a good stromboli in asheboro. I got a medium and it was the size of most places large. It had perfect cheese to meat ratio. I am blown away that these things have been hiding right under my nose this whole time. By far the best stromboli in town and don't let anyone else try to say otherwise because they are lying. I will be trying their pizza again solely because their stromboli is 🔥
Kyle HruskaKyle Hruska
00
I order from here fairly often and the blonde headed older lady is always rude, but tonight, I tried to place an order for pickup at 9:00 (online it says pickup until 9:30 and close at 9:00), and she said they will be gone by then that we have to pick up at 8:40. It's a Saturday night and we wouldn't be able to pick up any earlier than 9:00. I just cancelled the order (would have been at least $70 worth of food). I won't be ordering here anymore. The food is good and the cooks in the back are always nice, but they need a new front counter person. I'm tired of her! And who closes that early on a weekend? Just don't be open if that's the case.
ERICA REZAERICA REZA
00
This review is longggg overdue , I've been living in Asheboro for 2 years , moved from the Bronx! For this place to be called " Times Square Pizza " is a joke within itself !!! Sometimes I like their pizza and sometimes I don't , the cheese is always sliding off and the sauce be real watery , like in this picture here, so I'm really always taking a chance knowing half the times it's not gon be a good pie , I just need yall to get it together, even the buffalo wings don't be cooked right and I ask for them well done ! But I guess I will just start going to zekos even though it's a further drive.
Qua SantiagoQua Santiago
00
Nearby Attractions Of Time Square Pizza Downtown
Bicentennial Park
Compare Foods of Asheboro
Spectrum Store
Collector's Antique Mall
Asheboro Gold and Pawn
Antiques & Geeks Collectibles on Sunset
Sunset Theatre
Cardinal Rose Tattoo Gallery
The Flea Marketeers of Asheboro LLC
The Asheboro Farmers’ Market

Bicentennial Park
4.5
(297)Click for details

Compare Foods of Asheboro
3.9
(240)Click for details

Spectrum Store
3.4
(241)Click for details

Collector's Antique Mall
4.4
(160)Click for details
Nearby Restaurants Of Time Square Pizza Downtown
CJ's Olde Towne Restaurant
Magnolia 23
Flying Pig Food & Spirits
David's Restaurant
Cantina Taco Loco
Hamilton's Steakhouse
Brewskie’s
The Table
Four Saints Brewing Company
Hop's Bar-B-Q

CJ's Olde Towne Restaurant
4.7
(772)Click for details

Magnolia 23
4.8
(597)Click for details

Flying Pig Food & Spirits
4.4
(601)Click for details

David's Restaurant
4.3
(787)Click for details
Basic Info
Address
242 S Fayetteville St, Asheboro, NC 27203
Map
Phone
(336) 629-4579
Call
Website
ordertimessquarepizzeria.com
Visit
Reviews
Overview
4.4
(483 reviews)
Ratings & Description
attractions: Bicentennial Park, Compare Foods of Asheboro, Spectrum Store, Collector's Antique Mall, Asheboro Gold and Pawn, Antiques & Geeks Collectibles on Sunset, Sunset Theatre, Cardinal Rose Tattoo Gallery, The Flea Marketeers of Asheboro LLC, The Asheboro Farmers’ Market, restaurants: CJ's Olde Towne Restaurant, Magnolia 23, Flying Pig Food & Spirits, David's Restaurant, Cantina Taco Loco, Hamilton's Steakhouse, Brewskie’s, The Table, Four Saints Brewing Company, Hop's Bar-B-Q
