Anthony's Pizza & Catering — Restaurant in Bernardsville

This was the 2nd Pizzeria on the lunch time Pizza Hunt..O waited a good 10 minutes to be served as they were on the phone fielding a complaint about the food. This gave me time to menyander around the counter area. If this was an episode of Kitchen Nightmares, Gordon Ramsey would have attacked the amount of dust on the shelves and the amount on the fan that was over all of the Pizza. The outside appearance of the building itself was filthy. This is Bernardsville. Anyway, this led to the Pizza, which was not good. Simply as that. The man was pleasant behind the counter and provided good customer service. Maybe I caught them...

Ordered last night for delivery. Told the woman on the phone to make our pizza "well done with thin crust". The delivery driver was excellent with handling the situation when our pizza arrived undercooked and less than satisfactory; I believe his name was Chris. Great job Chris! They sent us another pizza free of charge but this time, it was burnt to a crisp and it took forever to get to our house. The woman on the phone was extremely rude, hence the 1 star. If Anthony's wants our business they'll do something about the woman on the phone who made my wife feel so uncomfortable. Until then, we are done...

Food was fine until we got to the "dessert pizza." It tasted like lighter fluid/fuel was poured over the crust and covered with nutella which made it inedible. We called Anthony's to notify them that their oven must have not been lit, causing the crust to be saturated in gas. Their response was condescending and dismissive. My biggest problem was not the terrible tasting Nutella pizza, but the lack of concern the restaurant showed for its own mistake. We were told that we would receive a call from the owner to discuss/rectify the situation, but not surprisingly, we still have not...