Gabe’s Bagels — Restaurant in Bridgewater Township

My first review of any place ever. I normally do not do this but felt the need to do so being that this place just opened. I ordered 4 bagels, two of which were Jalapeno Bagels. Instead of actually using Jalapenos they used red chili flakes in the Bagels. Not only that but the Bagels are left out in the open. 3 of the Bagels were hard, easily comparable to something you could get at your local grocery store. And to top it all off there was a piece of what looked like beard hair on the Red Chili Flake (advertised as Jalapeno) Bagel. The hair was not only on the Bagel but baked to the surface of the Bagel. They tried to make the establishment look as modern as possible but first impression is everything. It does not have a Bagel store feel to it. It doesn't even have a Deli Store feel to it. You go into Gabes Bagels and actually have to look around to see where the BAGELS are. The Bagel Spreads are on display instead of the Bagels. The actual Bagels are behind the counter and you have to practically lean over the counter to see the selection of Bagels, Some of which are near the floor in a basket hanging off the wall. Remember, the Bagels are out in the open. The guy who serviced me seemed more concerned about getting me out the door as fast as possible rather than a good first impression. I couldn't even get a "Thank you, come again" or anything. Instead he gave me back my card after I payed and immediately proceeded to service the person standing behind me before I could even grab my bag of Bagels. Again first impression is everything. I will not go back which is sad because there are no decent Bagel joints in the area. The added pictures are suppose to be Jalepeno Bagels. 100% it's...

Best Bagels & Even Better Community Spirit! Gabe’s Bagels is hands down the best bagel spot in town! Their bagels are everything you could ask for—crispy on the outside, perfectly chewy inside, and always fresh. Whether you’re grabbing a classic everything bagel with cream cheese or indulging in a loaded bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich, every bite is pure perfection.

Beyond the amazing food, I have to give a huge shoutout to Mo, the owner. Not only does he run an incredible bagel shop, but he’s also one of the kindest and most generous people around. He graciously allowed our Girl Scout troop to set up a cookie booth in front of his store, welcoming us with warmth and support. His kindness and generosity toward the girls did not go unnoticed, and we are truly grateful!

Gabe’s Bagels isn’t just a place for great food—it’s a place that truly supports the community. If you haven’t been yet, you’re missing out! Get there early because the favorites go fast....

New bagel place with really great bagels. My family will be coming here over the options in Basking Ridge/Bernardsville. I evaluate bagel shops on their mastery of four things:

Bagel consistency Ratios of bagel to cream cheese or bagel to egg/meat options Breakfast sandwiches as a whole Service** newly added because service at other local places has deteriorated as of recently

I would say Gabe’s has all four of these down better than any other. Bagels are fresh, kitchen is clean (you can see right in! They have nothing to hide!), service is quick (they answer the phone) and most importantly their ratios of bagel-cream cheese / bagel-egg and meat are superb. Definitely give them a go if you’re in the area or if you’re sick of your $10 breakfast sandwich having little to no meat on it. Gabe’s— you’re doing things right! Glad to have you guys...