Smith Bros. Pizza — Restaurant in City of Poughkeepsie

As a group of public safety dispatchers working night shift, we decided to try out Smith Bros since it's new. We ordered through slice and ordered almost one of every pizza. Slice called saying the driver had a miscommunication and could not pick up our order and they were canceling. Slice did not offer another alternative to me, other than going to get it myself, even after I explained that is not possible due to where we work. I called Smith Bros to see if there was anything they could do for us. Smith Bros got our order to us! We could not appreciate them more. The pizza itself was delicious, especially the dessert pizza 10/10. We will be ordering...

Tried your new venture last Sunday and was disappointed in the pies we ordered. Both pizzas were over cooked and cold after asking for 6 PM pick up. Arrived 5:50 PM and pizzas sitting on wire rack. Both young women working were busy on their cell phones. Very flat welcoming and not friendly experience. We have continued Joe Cristiano's repeat customers and will remain in moving forward providing pizza quality remains the same. As far as the new restaurant we will avoid as new style pizza's and service needs some...

Wow. I’ve been going through all the pizza places on DoorDash and most of them are average to bad and just a variation on the same style of pizza.

Next to Posto and Hudson and Packard this is the only place doing its OWN thing. The pizza has more a bar pie vibe to it and it is absolutely delicious.

Also had some of the garlic bread with cheese which was also really good.

We’ll definitely order...