The Mad Hatter Restaurant & Bakery
The Mad Hatter Restaurant & Bakery things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Plan your stay
Posts
This is a review of high tea. I thought this was a fun, different activity to do and I enjoyed it. It is pricey, but for a novel experience that is good for all ages, why not? Tea selection was large. All of the food was good. They give you a predetermined selection of treats on your two tiered tray, you don't order different items or flavors. However, they are very mindful of food allergies and restrictions. There are lots of vegan treats available in the bakery. I'm not sure if there is an upcharge for vegan treats during high tea. The tray had one of each item for each person at the table. There was a half cucumber sandwich, toasted bread with hummus and caramelized onions, and a ham roll up with mustard and cheese. For sweets, there were some scones, petit fours, berries, lemon bars, and cookies. The sweets were generous. I think if we could have traded one sweet for a savory item, we would have. Everything was very tasty though. I especially liked the cucumber sandwich and chocolate chip scone. There were sugar cubes, clotted cream, and butter on the table. It did take a while before we were served. Our cucumber water wasn't refilled while we were there. That being said, I liked the linens, table settings, decor, and vibe. It is really more of a casual vibe than fancy. Everyone there looked to be enjoying themselves. You don't get to be seated until everyone is there and parking is limited. I got there early and I was glad. Try to carpool if you can. After the hour mark they are happy to scoot you out, but I don't really mind this. It would be nice to have a way to do a tea sampler or flight, even if tea bags were used. Anyway, I enjoyed myself and it is something that I would come back and do with a different group of people. I am plus sized but was comfortable sitting on the green bench by the wall. The table looked like you could also push it out a little if needed. Read the website for all of the necessary details. 20% gratuity is automatically included, even with small parties. You can't be seated until your while party is there. Have realistic expectations and it will be a great mid-day activity.
Lisa MistrettaLisa Mistretta
00
The Mad Hatter Café is a charming local gem that exudes a warm, hometown feel. From the moment you walk in, the inviting atmosphere and friendly service create a cozy dining experience. Whether you’re stopping by for a morning coffee or a leisurely brunch, this café offers a welcoming space that feels both intimate and relaxed. One of the standout features of the menu is its impressive selection of duck dishes. The Duck Croque Madame is a must-try, elevating the classic French sandwich with rich, savory duck bacon. The balance of flavors, from the crispy bread to the perfectly runny egg, makes it a standout dish. If you’re a fan of duck, you’ll also appreciate the Duck BLT, which adds a flavorful twist to the traditional favorite. For those looking for a hearty breakfast, the breakfast plate is another solid option, offering a well-rounded selection of morning staples made with high-quality ingredients. The menu also features a variety of coffee options, catering to both classic and indulgent tastes. The caramel latte is smooth and well-balanced, while the chai latte offers a comforting blend of spices that’s perfect for a cozy morning pick-me-up. Beyond the savory offerings, The Mad Hatter Café also boasts an impressive selection of baked goods. Their in-house bakery serves up fresh pastries and sweets that perfectly complement their coffee options. Whether you’re in the mood for a flaky croissant or a rich, decadent dessert, the café ensures that there’s always something to satisfy your sweet tooth. With its inviting ambiance, thoughtfully crafted menu, and excellent coffee selection, The Mad Hatter Café is a delightful spot for breakfast, brunch, or a midday treat. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this café delivers a memorable dining experience that keeps guests coming back for more.
Chelsea AChelsea A
00
The food here was DELICIOUS. My boyfriend and I stumbled upon this place accidentally and my only regret is that I didn’t see this place sooner! The service was very friendly. The waiting area was a bit small and cramped and we had about a 30 minute wait, but it was the Saturday before Easter and it was busy as heck. The only bad part about it was a woman in the waiting area with her husband and children who was miserable because they were waiting too long. The staff was waiting for a group who was finishing up their meal to leave, and I’m pretty sure she wanted the staff to go in there and ask them to leave (not how it works). The woman was impatient and the staff handled it very well despite the pressure and how busy they were and I was very impressed! ANYWAYS...the food was great. I got eggs Benedict and I don’t think a day has gone by that I have not thought about it, it was that good. I think it was called the Hatter? My boyfriend got the Hatter plate and that was equally as good. Along with it we got fresh fruit and mimosas (fresh squeezed orange juice and a great price too). I can’t wait to go here again and try out more food! We didn’t get a chance to try the bakery items but I don’t doubt they are delicious as well. The price was good, service was good, food was good. I recommend this place for sure! Note: they don’t take reservations! So depending when you go, expect that you could be waiting, but it’s worth it!
Courtney SouleCourtney Soule
00
What a fantastic restaurant!! We are from out of town and wanted a delicious breakfast place with gluten free options…the Mad Hatter delivered!! So much so that we came back two more times in 4 days. Once for High Tea and then again for Sunday brunch on Easter. (Which we were sat within 5 minutes even though it was a packed restaurant) The Mad Hatter’s food is delicious and fresh. The potatoes, avocado crème, fresh fruit, pesto chicken, frittata and high tea sandwiches and desserts are all tasty. The gluten free options are spot on. The food is worth the price. The environment is cozy and the service is excellent. All the wait staff are polite, friendly, welcoming and on top of their game. Mikayla is an absolute stand out! She served us the first day as well as during high tea. She made great friendly conversation and even remembered us the last day for brunch and asked about how my daughter’s swim meet went! (we were in town for a large swim meet) If you are in town or even a local, I highly recommend The Mad Hatter!!
TamTam
00
Nearby Attractions Of The Mad Hatter Restaurant & Bakery
George Eastman Museum
The Strathallan Rochester Hotel & Spa - a DoubleTree by Hilton
Memorial Art Gallery
Parkleigh
RMSC (Rochester Museum & Science Center)
Dorje Adornments
Archimage
Central Rock Gym
Happy Feet Spa
Figgy Studio & Shop

George Eastman Museum
4.7
(1.2K)
Click for details

The Strathallan Rochester Hotel & Spa - a DoubleTree by Hilton
4.4
(835)
Click for details

Memorial Art Gallery
4.8
(692)
Click for details

Parkleigh
4.7
(472)
Click for details
Nearby Restaurants Of The Mad Hatter Restaurant & Bakery
Dogtown
Jines Restaurant
Han Noodle Bar
Blu Wolf Bistro
The Owl House
Aladdin's Natural Eatery
The Red Fern
Mark's Texas Hots
ROAM Cafe
Cedar

Dogtown
4.7
(1.6K)
Click for details

Jines Restaurant
4.6
(1.3K)
Click for details

Han Noodle Bar
4.4
(900)
Click for details

Blu Wolf Bistro
4.3
(893)
Click for details
Basic Info
Address
176 S Goodman St, Rochester, NY 14607
Map
Phone
(585) 545-4985
Call
Website
madhatterrestaurantandbakery.com
Visit
Reviews
Overview
4.5
(632 reviews)
Ratings & Description
Description
Charming place offering cafe fare for breakfast & lunch along with British high tea & baked goods.
attractions: George Eastman Museum, The Strathallan Rochester Hotel & Spa - a DoubleTree by Hilton, Memorial Art Gallery, Parkleigh, RMSC (Rochester Museum & Science Center), Dorje Adornments, Archimage, Central Rock Gym, Happy Feet Spa, Figgy Studio & Shop, restaurants: Dogtown, Jines Restaurant, Han Noodle Bar, Blu Wolf Bistro, The Owl House, Aladdin's Natural Eatery, The Red Fern, Mark's Texas Hots, ROAM Cafe, Cedar
