Tony's Pizzeria — Restaurant in City of Utica

The Lasgna was burnt on one half and seemingly undercooked on the other. Not to mention when they reheated it in their oven, it was still fridge-cold in several places. Furthermore, their ground meat was loaded with chewy bits that I couldn't get down. Absolutely the worst Lasgna I've had. My significant other also pointed out the chips that she got were seriously passed their expiration date. We've tried this place twice together and ordered different things each time. We have concluded: The reheated dinners and sandwiches aren't good, although we never tried the pizza after our first two bad experiences. The ordering process is confusing and we had no way to know if/when our order would be done. In fact, one time I saw what appeared to be our sandwich, sitting done, behind the counter for almost 20 minutes, while people who ordered slices zipped in and out ahead of us. From what I could tell, it turned out the person who made the sandwich was waiting for Lasgna to come out of the oven, and nobody had ever put the Lasgna in the oven... Nobody cares if you are satisfied. We sat in the restaurant to eat our food. Neither of us could finish the food and we threw it out knowing it was not going to be any better leftover. As we left it had quieted down, and out of 4 people behind the counter, nobody said a word to us.

I hate leaving scathing reviews, but there are literally pizza shops and Italian / American restaurants on every block and I can't for the life of me understand how this one could be soo bad. The only reason I fell for this place twice is because it is right on my drive...

4/3/24 update something has drastically changed here, this is the 3rd pizza I've received that the crust/ pizza dough is bad! It is uncooked, flat, doesn't rise like normal. I tried to brown in my oven and it just will not brown, it just gets hard but not brown. it completely ruins the pizza which used to be my favorite. The pepperoni sub & greens & beans were delicious. Tiramasu was awesome. Tonys what is going on with your pizza crust??? Even the sausage roll is no longer tasty. Something has definitely been changed. I hope they correct or I will find another pizza place.

Love their pizza, they have the best tasting sausage of any pizza places locally. Meatballs are also delicious. Sausage roll worth the cost, very large. Greens & beans is usually very fresh & very tasty. I've had subs, as well. The only thing I wouldn't recommend is fish fry as it's frozen fish & not very good.. but overall this place has...

Just ordered a small turkey with everything. They sure mean a small, no question about that. I think it was a 4 inch with barely any meat on it.

They should be ashamed of themselves. Subway gives you more on a 6 inch and they basically weigh their product.

The pizza was super greasy as well. I would avoid this place, it seems to have gone down hill.

Response; I can guarantee you this is the correct location and that small definitely was not 8 inches and had barely anything on it. Maybe you should have more quality control with your employees making the food? I wish I took a picture. Your subs used to be great, a small was comparable to Venice. This isn't the case...