Todaro's Pizza is an absolute gem! From the moment you step inside, you know you’re in for a treat. Their pizza is nothing short of amazing—every bite is a testament to their commitment to quality and authenticity. The dough is perfection: airy yet chewy, with just the right amount of crispness on the crust. You can tell it’s made fresh daily.
The sauce is a masterpiece—rich, flavorful, and seasoned to perfection. It strikes that perfect balance of sweet and tangy, and you can taste the quality of the tomatoes they use. And then there’s the cheese—oh, the cheese! Melted to gooey perfection, it’s creamy, flavorful, and clearly of the highest quality. Together, it creates a pizza experience that’s pure bliss.
Beyond the food, the service at Todaro’s Pizza is exceptional. The staff is warm, friendly, and always ready to go the extra mile to make your visit memorable. And let’s talk about their speed—they work like a well-oiled machine! Whether you’re dining in or ordering takeout, your pizza is ready in no time, yet it never feels rushed or anything less than perfect.
If you’re a pizza lover (and who isn’t?), Todaro’s is a must-visit. They’ve truly set the standard for what great pizza and service should be. I can’t recommend them...
Read moreI was very disappointed. Stopped in during parade daughter was performing. Just moved here from Monmouth NJ. I was raised in Keyport, NJ when I was a kid off route 36 ( Hazlet NJs neighboring town). Anyway, I was over the moon seeing a familiar town on the sign outside. I asked the people inside about the pizza place and excited for NJ/NY pizza and they just shrugged their shoulders unamused about how excited I was, I get it teenagers working at a pizza place during a parade. They said the owner is very Italian. I got a slice to go. I couldn’t taste anything. The dough had no salt no flavor, sauce had no flavor either. It was thin like a NJ/NY pizza but that’s it. It must be true, need water from the Raritan Bay for a truly good dough. Being Italian I was very upset I was looking forward towards NJ pizza. Maybe it was just a bad batch of dough, maybe I’ll give it another try next time...
Read moreIf there is a way to give a zero star review on this place, I will do it in a heartbeat. First of all, my friend and I just had a personal pizza from this establishment and me and my friend were thinking the crust would be thick even though it was a smaller sized pizza. Second of all that was not the case this pizza had the thinnest crust I’ve ever had. Third of all this pizza or giant cracker did not even taste good at all due to the crust or cracker having zero flavor. Fourth of all there was barely any toppings on the pizza or cracker as well. And what bothers me the most is the price Nine dollars for a build your own pizza or cracker that has cheese on it with one topping . That is what I call a scam. Don’t waste your time getting pizza or crackers from this pizza and cracker joint. To be honest, the crust or cracker taste like cardboard anyways I would not recommend this...
Read more