New York Richie's Pizza and Sandwiches — Restaurant in Garden City

New York Richie's is right down the road from us and I have never been here before. My husband has been here and said they had really good pizza. My husband is pizza snob so I trust his opinion on pizza. I wanted pizza for dinner so New York Richie's sounded perfect.

Walking in, this place is clean! I love seeing all the New York style decor. There's also a cool pool table in the back. Kinda cool that you can come get a slice here, play pool and chill.

The nice man behind the window helped us tonight. He gave us a minute to check out the menu. After checking it out, we decided on half cheese half Maui pizza. We also grabbed some garlic parm fries to start with.

We were chillin, sippin on our drinks. I got sweet green tea. Mannnnn the tea is so good! Theres several places in town that serve "sweet tea" and it's not even sweet. Whatever they are serving, it is so good! Our fries got dropped off while we were sippin on our beverages. The fries were hot! They were generously coated in parm cheese and garlic. The fries were perfectly seasoned so ketchup was unnecessary. The garlic was crunchy and roasted. The saltiness of the parm was a great addition to the fries. I could eat bits of the roasted garlic. It was all so good!

Our pizza came out shortly. It was pipping hot! I grabbed a slice of the Maui and the cheese was sliding off. You had to wait a minute to eat the slice or you would have burned your mouth. I love when pizza is that fresh! The crust was so thin and chewy! The pie had the right amount of sauce to cheese. The pineapple was my favorite part of the pizza. I love the sweet and savory from the pepperoni. I do wish there was more pineapple to pep so I'll have to order it that way next time! My husband smashed 3 out of his 4 slices so you know he was happy. I took my other 3 slices home and I look forward to enjoying them later.

If you're looking for a great slice or whole pie, New York Richie's is your joint to hit up. They also have salads and sandwiches as well which is a great option to have. Happy I got to come in tonight and support this family owned pizza joint. I look forward to...

These people do a great job creating delicious pizza. Friendly on-time delivery and really good location on Glenwood and. Marigold. Next to another favorite... Pastry Perfection. Best American and Indian pizzas, ever. . 5-4-22 I realize this is a 2nd review (one year or so later) of New York Richie's, but this week I was looking to find a fantastic New York Style Cheesecake for some of my best friends, Jack Kaufman who's 92 and his wife Shirley. Now and then my lovely lady Anne and myself arrive at Jack's home to prepare with honor and culinary perfection, an incredible meal. We've been doing this for years and it's one of my favorite things, to leverage joy, happiness and great food into a gift of love. All that said, the Pacific Sockeye fillet meal and wonderful conversation had to be paired with a dessert, and my lifetime pursuit of perfect Cheesecake continued. Store-bought wasn't going to pair nicely so I looked at area restaurants and local pastry shops, and thought hey! what about New York Richie's? They have 'New York' in their name and the best pizza on the planet (I've been going to those folks for years) so maybe they have the one dessert I needed. Got on their website, found they had cheesecake, for nearly $7/slice. For four friends, that's $28 for cheesecake. I phoned Richie's for a short conversation, and the humble guy who's for years taken my orders for Pepperoni pizza (love), Hawaiian pizza (extra love) as well as Chicken Tikka pizza (yes they specialize in authentic Indian tikka, curry, paneer, maharaja and etc etc) and behold, they sell cheesecake. So I coughed-up the $28 along with a jar of select strawberry preserves. Trust me oh please trust me, New York Richie's has the best thick-cut cheesecake I've ever tasted! At 65 years and as a non-professional Chef I incredibly recommend New York Richie's New York...

Beyond satisfying -- New York Richie's is SO GOOD. (and family-owned, which I love for Boise so much!) Almost every order from me is the delicious Reuben sandwich (no fat, my choice of mustard, hot & toasted!) though I order the Coconut Lover pizza w/ Chicken just as often when I'm ordering for larger parties (if you're intrigued -- trust me, it's incredible). My BF loves their create-your-own style pizza with mushrooms & pepperoni. SO delicious. When I say droolworthy... and FAST + Friendly / Super Accommodating -- I mean it. There's no wait time, pizzas are savory & hot, mango lassi's are sweet & cold... and NY Richie's is the only place I've found nearby that serves Ace Pear cider (with all the kind & personal service of a family-owned restaurant). PLUS -- there's jazzy pool in the back for extra lounging vibes.10/10 every time, New York Richie's knocks it out of the park with their genius blend of Indian & Italian. Boise is lucky to have them! Highly HIGHLY recommend. And don't forget to try the thin-crust Indian Pizza! 5+++ stars for high-quality ingredients, high-quality service, high-quality menu for every taste of...