Toni's Pizza
Toni's Pizza things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Description
Ratings
Posts
Toni's Pizza is the best NY style pizza I've found in Ohio yet! Only here for less than 6 months I'm so glad I found this hidden gem. It's owned and operated by Toni himself and you can taste the difference in the pizza made here. After searching for and finding the place I'd order pizza from, I placed a call and put my order in. It was quick, easy and pizza was ready in 20 minutes. I chose to pick up so I could see the location and learn more about this new pizza spot. They also offer delivery, and they are open till 4 am!!! They even have more than just pizza! Burgers and wings are on the menu also, as well as subs. For desert lovers, the cheesecake is out of this world! We ordered the cheesy bread and an 18" pepperoni pizza. Prices here are great and the quality is above and beyond. First the cheesy bread was sooo tasty and their marinara paired with it just had my taste buds singing. The pepperoni pizza had me feeling like I was back in NY enjoying a slice. So happy I stumbled across this and took a chance. Top of my list for future pizza nights!
Ashley CallahanAshley Callahan
20
above average pizza. odd cashier. said “thank you so much” atleast a dozen times in the span of taking order over the phone and receiving payment. opens for business at 2pm and then stays open really late which doesnt make any sense to me why they wouldnt be open at 11am like most other pizza places. seems to cater to people that head out to the bars at night or perhaps enjoys the patronage of those that partake on alcoholic beverages. i was told lakewood has bars. i moved here during a pandemic and i dont partake in nightlife so i wouldnt know how busy it gets but the hours of this establishment and few other pizza places in this area leaves me a bit confused on the priorities of the regional demographics. people dont seem particularly festive in this area but they partake in a sizeable nightlife enough so that businesses cater to them in late hours??? anyways this is the first local pizzeria whose pizza was actually decent. i wouldnt say the pizza is superb but considering how bad the pizza is in this city this place is well above average.
승엽승엽
00
So I am obsessed with their veggie burger always soo good , and typically l can’t resist but order the veggie sub also. SoOoo Good ! Always , every time!! I actually did pick up for the first time , placed an order online very convenient, and super easy! I was able to use Apple Pay, online! Love the convenience! I walked in to pick up my order , yet this yummy carrot cake is starting right at me! Omg sooo goooood. The staff is so extremely friendly, I asked if they did Apple Pay in store, the guy was wayyyy too generous and offered it on the house I was beyond shocked! I myself am in the service Industry, as a small business owner and I completely understand that times have been tough this year, abd last year! The overall generosity and kind and friendly staff goes a long way, and it was such a great experience! Deepest thank you from the bottom of my heart for continuing to keep your doors open and serving AMAZING food EVERY TIME! So the veggie sub is already in my belly along with most of the carrot cake! Soo good!
Flory MohanFlory Mohan
20
I have been sleeping on this place! I always thought due to its random little location and not hearing much about it that it was a little more of a divey late night fast food spot, on the way home from work I was randomly craving pizza they were open, and they delivered! Cheesy bread ready literally the exact minute I was told they would be, such great flavor, the right amount of seasoning, soft flaky crust with just the right hint of garlic?and I'm really picky about my crusts AND cheese. I like a Lotta seasoning! I was super happy with what I got, and the two guys working on this Monday evening were super fast and friendly even an hour before close. Thanks for filling my craving!
Alyssa PatchinAlyssa Patchin
10
The pizza is subpar at best and overpriced for sure. The wings are advertised as jumbo wings and by the pound. Well a pound there gets you 6 little tiny wings for 13 bucks and the pizza they add in 15 dollars for a large. Making that a 35 dollar pizza which may be worth It if it were good. The sauce. Omg I wish a video could be posted here. The blue cheese was as thin as water and chunky but not in any kinda of good way. Its 1.5 per container. I ordered two ex tr ra and just ended up pouring it out. This is absolutely disgusting and i promise you'll agree if you do try this. One pizza and 6 wings. 52 dollars. Just fyi
Jeremy MuzzyJeremy Muzzy
20
Boy oh Boy! First discovered this place March 2020 due to lockdown and covid. Traditional styled New York / Philly / Jersey slices. Thin, foldable, melt in your mouth, cracker like yet chewy crust. Wings phenomenal, appetizers great. Service awesome. Fast forward 2021 of July. Hankering for a cheese steak. I’d frequent Philly regularly and grown accustomed to the working mans hoagie. Well not taking a 6 hour drive to Philly so I went searching in Cleveland. GET YOUR CHEESESTEAK HERE! Better than anything in Philly! I’m Philly it’s widely known, you get your cheese steaks from a pizza shop. Why didn’t I figure that out!?!?!
Michael JervinskyMichael Jervinsky
60
Nearby Attractions Of Toni's Pizza
Doki Doki Anime & Kawaii Shop
Cove Park
Cleveland Clinic - Lakewood Family Health Center
Lakewood High School Natatorium
The Nicholson House
Paisley Monkey
Flame & Fable

Doki Doki Anime & Kawaii Shop
4.8
(127)Click for details

Cove Park
4.4
(111)Click for details

Cleveland Clinic - Lakewood Family Health Center
3.0
(94)Click for details

Lakewood High School Natatorium
4.4
(31)Click for details
Nearby Restaurants Of Toni's Pizza
Melt Bar and Grilled
Winking Lizard Lakewood
Angelo's Pizza
Woodstock BBQ
Forage Public House
Aladdin's Eatery Lakewood
Corky's Place
Pepper's Italian Restaurant
Greek Village Grille
Gray Dog Diner

Melt Bar and Grilled
4.3
(1.5K)$$
Click for details

Winking Lizard Lakewood
4.4
(1.1K)$$
Click for details

Angelo's Pizza
4.6
(2.4K)$$
Click for details

Woodstock BBQ
4.6
(799)$$
Click for details