Papa Johns Pizza — Restaurant in Manhattan

My overall review is purely based on the taste of the pizza.

My method of receiving my pizza was me getting in a Rodney and driving there to pick it up bringing my (heat retaining) bag to zip my stuff in to keep it hot till I get back home. So this isn't based off any delivery service either.

I've ordered that large garlic stuff crust pizza with pepperoni and extra cheese. That pizza came out pretty good. Good flavor overall (the kind of mainstream good flavor, not gourmet pizza good). I would recommend giving that pizza a try if that's something you're into.

Now the cheese sticks....I wish I had a heads-up on the cheese sticks. They were very blah by design....not because they didn't make it good. They are almost like thin crust crust with some dried out cheese on top.

I've ordered this on a Thursday night and my pizza was ready in like 18-20mins. Staff was vibrant and very professional although all I had to do when I got there was tell them my name and they gave me my pizza/cheese sticks in my hand and I was on my way.

I've seen the reviews on here with unhappy customers and happy customers. Just remember you will always have your own experience. Be mindful of busy times to order and remember dam near everyone is short staffed and you'll be ok. Happy eating! And make someone...

Ordered a pizza from here a couple of days ago. To my surprise I had the most wonderful man on the other end of the line. He made sure that everything I was looking for ( I was hosting a party at the time) was to be on my order and not to miss one item. He repeated my order back to me and double checked the toppings. He even offered me napkins and plates!!!! If I can remember the gentlemen said his name was Layton. He is an outstanding employee and should defiantly should know about his hard work paying off! Thanks for making my night with the Papa, a great one! Ill be sure to order again next time I host an event at my house. Until next time, The man...

They used to be my go 2 pizza place that is changing now i will no longer cast my vote with this company.....both of the last times i ordered from them they told me 33 minutes took over 1 hour and 30 minutes they are using door dash 4 delivery even if u dont use doordash ur now forced if u choose papa johns so count on alot of cold pizza complaints and their response to mine was "well i dont know what to tell you".....I feel like quality has gone right out the window for $30+ dollars u are better off eating at lil ceasers atleast there u can feed more than 1...