Castaway Waterfront Restaurant & Sushi Bar — Restaurant in Marathon

A Serene Culinary Haven: Castaways Waterfront Restaurant

Nestled along the tranquil canal, Castaways Waterfront Restaurant is a hidden gem that captivates both the palate and the soul. This extraordinary dining destination not only boasts amazing food but also offers a unique connection with nature, as a manatee family graces the waters just outside its doors.

From the moment you step foot into Castaways, you are greeted by an atmosphere of relaxation and serenity. The interior decor exudes coastal charm, with soft hues, nautical accents, and large windows that provide breathtaking views of the canal. The ambiance is perfectly complemented by the gentle presence of the manatee family, adding an enchanting touch to your dining experience.

Castaways' culinary offerings are nothing short of extraordinary. The diverse menu caters to a wide range of tastes, but one standout feature is their sushi selection. The sushi here is simply exceptional. From classic rolls to innovative creations, each piece is a work of art, meticulously crafted with the freshest ingredients. The skillful chefs pay utmost attention to detail, ensuring that every bite is a burst of exquisite flavors. Whether you're a sushi connoisseur or a newcomer to this Japanese delicacy, Castaways will undoubtedly leave you craving more.

However, Castaways isn't just about sushi; the entire menu is a culinary delight. From succulent seafood dishes to perfectly grilled steaks and a variety of vegetarian options, there is something to satisfy every palate. The quality of the ingredients shines through in each dish, showcasing the restaurant's commitment to providing an exceptional dining experience.

As you savor your meal, the backdrop of the manatee family adds a touch of magic to the dining experience. These gentle creatures gracefully swim by, creating a sense of harmony between humans and nature. It's a rare and awe-inspiring sight that sets Castaways apart from other restaurants.

The attentive and friendly staff at Castaways deserve special mention. Their warm hospitality and knowledge of the menu enhance the overall dining experience. They are more than happy to provide recommendations or accommodate special requests, ensuring that every guest feels welcomed and well taken care of.

To top it all off, Castaways offers a well-curated selection of beverages, including handcrafted cocktails and an impressive wine list. These drinks perfectly complement the flavors of the food, allowing you to indulge in a truly unforgettable dining experience.

In conclusion, Castaways Waterfront Restaurant is a haven for food enthusiasts seeking an exceptional culinary adventure. From the incredible sushi to the diverse menu, every aspect of this dining establishment reflects a dedication to excellence. Coupled with the presence of the manatee family, the ambiance becomes truly extraordinary. Whether you're a local resident or a visitor to the area, a visit to Castaways is an experience that will leave you with memories to cherish...

Extremely Disappointing Experience – Visitors Beware

While visiting a resort in Marathon, FL, my family and I were unable to dine at the on-site restaurant due to it being fully booked. We searched for a nearby option and even though Castaway Waterfront Restaurant did not have but one Vegetarian option, we found promising reviews for the restaurant.

Unfortunately, our experience was anything but positive — and I feel compelled to share this for others visiting the area, especially those from diverse backgrounds.

From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere was unwelcoming. The hostess barely acknowledged us — no greeting, no eye contact, just a dismissive attitude that immediately made us feel like we were not welcome. Sadly, this set the tone for the rest of the evening.

We were seated and introduced to our server, Courtney. We placed our appetizer order, which arrived quickly, giving us some initial hope. However, after that, things went downhill fast. We waited over an hour for our entrees while watching tables around us — many of whom had arrived well after we did — being served their meals promptly.

When I asked Courtney for an update, she responded curtly: “I already told you that your food was coming right out.” Not only was this response unnecessarily rude, but it felt like our concerns were being brushed aside. She started to walk away and I called her back. When I pointed out that other tables were being served before us, her response was even more dismissive: “Last time I checked your ticket was third in line, I only put in the order, I do not work the kitchen.” I also indicated that we had been waiting for an hour.

That level of arrogance and lack of accountability was infuriating. Whether she forgot to put in our order, it was poor service, intentional disregard, or just plain negligence, it completely ruined our evening. In the end, we were so upset that we didn’t even eat our meals. We asked for take-out boxes and left. $160 wasted on a dinner we didn’t get to enjoy.

As a Hispanic family visiting from Miami, we couldn’t shake the feeling that we were being treated differently — and not in a good way. If you’re a visitor, especially someone who looks or sounds “not local,” think twice before dining here.

What should have been a memorable culinary experience in the Florida Keys became a night of frustration and disappointment....

Tucked into a cozy corner of the city, [Restaurant Name] delivers an exceptional Mexican dining experience that is hard to match. From the moment you step inside, the vibrant decor—featuring colorful murals, rustic wooden tables, and strings of papel picado—sets a welcoming and festive tone. The staff greeted us warmly and provided attentive service throughout our visit, ensuring we felt like valued guests. The atmosphere struck a perfect balance between casual and lively, making it an ideal spot for both family dinners and gatherings with friends.

The menu is a celebration of Mexican culinary tradition, offering a wide variety of dishes ranging from familiar classics to regional specialties. We started with the freshly made guacamole, served with warm, lightly salted tortilla chips. The guacamole was creamy and rich, with just the right kick of lime and cilantro. For the main course, the carne asada tacos stole the show—perfectly seasoned and grilled, paired with fresh pico de gallo and a side of smoky salsa roja. My companion opted for the mole enchiladas, which featured tender chicken bathed in a complex, slightly sweet sauce with hints of chocolate and spices.

One of the standout features of [Restaurant Name] is their commitment to authenticity and quality. The ingredients tasted incredibly fresh, and it was evident that great care went into crafting each dish. The drink menu was equally impressive, boasting an array of margaritas, micheladas, and Mexican beers. We couldn’t resist trying the house margarita, which was perfectly balanced and served with a generous rim of salt. For dessert, the flan was a delightful conclusion to our meal, with its silky texture and caramel richness.

While the food and atmosphere were exceptional, there were minor areas for improvement. The wait for our entrées was slightly longer than expected, though the quality of the food made it worth the wait. Additionally, the restaurant can get quite busy during peak hours, so reservations are recommended. Overall, [Restaurant Name] is a must-visit for anyone seeking authentic Mexican cuisine and a warm, inviting dining experience. We left thoroughly satisfied and eager to return to explore more of their...