Godfather's Pizza — Restaurant in Miamisburg

Godfather's Pizza is absolutely delicious and the people there took good care of us.

NOTE THOUGH: Apparently, delivery service is provided by DoorDash, not an in-house service. We discovered this when our Dasher left our pizza literally in the snow and did not knock on our door or text or do ANYTHING to let us know our pizza had arrived. We are very sure we didn't just 'miss' the knock because my husband is about 6feet away from the door at all times, and has incredibly sensitive hearing. And, we also have a cat who usually responds vividly to any noise from outside. Order delivery at your own risk!

That said, they are well worth the effort to carry-out if you can manage it. And they refunded our pizza - even though the dasher's poor delivery was not remotely their fault - and replaced our pizza for free. We went to pick it up this time and they even gave me a coupon for a free monkey bread/dessert next time.

Their pizza is delicious; it is my platonic ideal of a pizza. The sauce is great, the cheese somehow amazingly gooey and yet the slices somehow manage to stay distinct instead of oozing back into each other, the pepperoni get just a hint of crisp at the edges without getting too crunchy, and the dough has just a little bit of pleasant chewiness and supports all the pizza on top of it exquisitely.

We are so grateful they offered to remake our pizza for us, AND refund us, even though our cold pizza was not remotely their fault...

I ordered a pizza from here online for delivery on 04/15/2022 .Delivery time was suppose to be at 6:30 pm.It was a first date for me and this man.He loves taco pizza so I told him I would order us one.I ordered half taco and half combo as taco pizza can not be heated due to lettuce.I called godfathers about my order around 6:45 they said they was waiting on door dash to pick it up.Around 710 pm the lady from godfathers called me and said door dash finally picked it up and said call me when it has been delivered and I will refund your money.So when pizza arrived at approximately 720 I called store back and a young girl asked me to hold but hung up on me. Godfathers is just as guilty as door dash driver as they sent me cold nasty hard pizza.Nine days later no refund you can keep it obviously you need it more then I do.I will NEVER ORDER...

I love the pizza here and it’s really good and the people are nice that work there at the pizza place. My favorite movie is the godfather so when I go here it makes me think of the godfather “So you come to me on the day of my daughters wedding for the favor” from the godfather just like the pizza place. I got a pizza here the other day and then o went to Home Depot and bought some screws so I could put my license plate on my car. It was really cool because I got pizza and then Home Depot was right there so I could just walk over. They have a really good bathroom at the godfathers pizza too because it was really clean. It reminded me of the scene where Michael Corleone goes to the bathroom in the godfather. Overall I really like godfathers pizza and I love the movie...