Steel City Pizza — Restaurant in Middletown

My husband and I had the wonderful opportunity of having steel city cater for our wedding. They are so nice, and kind. They pay attention to detail and guests absolutely LOVED the pizza. My wedding day had quite a heatwave and not one time did any of the steel city team let that stop them from being of service to us and our guests. They kept smiles on their faces, and we're just absolutely so very nice. I appreciate them, the hard work they put in to ensure food was ready, and the positivity they had the entire time they were there!

They blessed us with a wedding gift and even made us a heart shaped pizza, which was so awesome, cool and very kind. Nicole was great to work with! She's so sweet, and tried her best to be very attentive on our day. Thank you so much for catering my event, we will forever...

Ordered the pizza on DoorDash. The pictures don't let you know that you're receiving what amounts to a personal pizza. Very disappointed in the size of the pizza, especially considering the cost.

Size aside, the toppings slid right off the crust when you pick up a slice, and the crust doesn't have that great fire flavor you associate with charcoal fired pizza; it tasted downright burnt.

0/10, would not recommend.

Edit: when I called to make sure I got the correct pizza the recording said they don't take orders over the phone and hung up. You can't call this location to...

We have been wanting to try steel city for awhile. I’ve followed them on instagram for a good bit. Let me tell you, it was well worth the wait. We got a pepperoni and a margarita pizza. The crust was perfect, sauce was wonderful and just an all around great pizza, dare I say delightful. I’m so glad this building is finally being used. I’m born and raised in the Middie and I really try and support local restaurants. Give this place a try. Neat atmosphere with them being attached to NEW...