The Mill Steakhouse + Spirits — Restaurant in Milton

My partner and I heard about this place through coworkers! We ended up coming her for our anniversary. From the minute you walk into the entrance, we were greeted with a warm welcoming by the hosts, then seated and that’s where the service was off to a wonderful start, which is a great thing. The experience from the staff to the wine, cocktails, appetizers and the entrees were amazing. When we were seated we were asked if we were celebrating anything special and we mentioned our anniversary. Shortly after wards we were greeted by our server(we forgot to get his name) but we would remember him in a heart beat. He explained amazing and specific details of the menu and then introduced us to his favorites. We ended up going with his favorites and we did NOT regret the choices. We started of with the avocado shrimp and half a dozen oysters. The flavors of the shrimp were bursting and their oysters were fresh only to me because I love oysters and these were not overwhelming like how other oysters have been to my taste. Also the shrimp had a little kick to it but again the flavors blended so well and it evened out the kick of spice it had to it. My partner ordered a cocktail and I ordered the Mill Sunset cocktail. It was a wonderful choice but the wine that was also recommended occupied my attention all night. My partner was just starting out with drinking wine and so he asked if there was a specific way to drink good quality wine(never be too scared to ask) and the server we had explained how to drink it and the quality of the wine purchased. Following specific instructions, my partner enjoyed that wine and ended up purchasing another bottle for family and friends for the following day. As we waited for our entrees we were very pleased with the setting, it was warm and very welcoming to us. The entrees that we ordered were our servers recommendations and we did not regret our decision to order. We ordered the King Salmon and a 32ounce TOMHAWK RIBEYE and the flavors, the way they all blended was truly satisfying to our tastebuds and felt as if they just all melted right into our mouths. We loved the choices and so we thank our server so much for being so specific with the menu. We ate everything by the way and we will be bringing friends and family back. At the end of the night we ended up receiving desert from the staff there for our anniversary and that definitely made the ending to our night. The staff was very much attentive to us and checked on us at the appropriate times, while dining. We love the Milk and it was our first time there. Thank you guys so much for the experience! Well worth it! Keep up the amazing work, your presence did not...

Regretful Trip Down Memory Lane

Rating: ★☆☆☆☆

To say my recent experiences at The Mill Steakhouse have been disappointing would be an understatement. This eatery, that was one day buzzing with top-notch service, delightful dishes, and an inviting atmosphere, seems to have taken a bitter turn, leaving a distinct sour taste. A week ago, my family and I revisited for a midday meal, and the service was exceptional. A commendable waiting staff was congenial and attentive, making an effort to engage my two-year-old, which was a delightful touch. The menu recommendations they provided were perceived well, and the inferred satisfaction left content smiles all around. Nonetheless, the night resulted in a distressing bout of illness for my entire family. For a moment, we dismissed it as an unfortunate coincidence, considering we had dined out the previous night as well. In a bid to salvage fond memories and give the venue another chance, we dropped by for our once-favorite Sunday brunch. Alas, the day held a vastly different and unpleasant experience. The waitress who served us had an unsavory attitude and appeared irascibly inconvenienced by any requested interaction. Indifference dripped from her every word as if we had committed some grave error by being there. When i pointed out stains on my silverware roll, she callously dismissed it, saying "it's normal, we always have stains." This complete disregard for basic hygiene was startling and unacceptable. My consequential cuisine, a medium rear New York steak that used to be a flavorful treat, was reduced to an inedible burnt mass. Disheartened, I watched my $80 blissfully circle the drain with this course. To further exacerbate the situation, a repeat of our last visit ensued. Even after spending over $450 for a meal, we all fell sick again, this time with four adults and my toddler. I deeply regret to bid goodbye to what used to be one of my favorite haunts. It is heart-wrenchingly depressing to witness this drastic downgrade. Whether it is a change in management or just an overall decline in standards, The Mill Steakhouse is an alarming disappointment. If I were to take anything from this dispiriting experience, it is simply a confirmation of my resolve - not to return to this establishment anytime soon I caution perspective visitors to take this review into due consideration before making any dining...

Disappointing Service needs to improve:

Food Quality: 4 Stars Prices: 3 Stars Facility/Ambiance: 4 Stars Service: 2.5 Stars Restaurant Overall Review - 3.5 Stars

We (Party of 10) recently dined at a restaurant and would like to share my review. Overall, I would rate it 3.5 stars based on the following criteria:

Food Quality: 4 Stars First and foremost, the food at this restaurant was of good quality. I opted for a Prime Rib dish that was delicious, flavorful and the ingredients tasted fresh. The menu offered a variety of limited options, and the presentation of the dishes was appealing. We thoroughly enjoyed the taste and creativity of the food.

Prices: 3 Stars One aspect that I found slightly disappointing was the pricing. While the food was good, I felt that the prices were a bit high for the portion sizes and overall experience. Some dishes seemed overpriced for what they offered. It would have been better if the prices were more reasonable and better aligned with the quality of the food.

Facility/Ambiance: 4 Stars The restaurant had a pleasant and inviting ambiance. The decor was tastefully done, and the seating arrangements were comfortable. The facility accomodated our party of 10 by providing the corner of the dining area, in which allowed some privacy. In addition, the lighting and music added to the overall atmosphere. The restaurant also had a clean and well-maintained facility, which contributed positively to the dining experience.

Service: 2.5 Stars Unfortunately, the service was the weakest aspect of our experience. In my personal experiences, excellent service is the essential to a wonderful and memoriable dining experience. Our waiter seemed inattentive to our service request and often time we would initiate service. It took a while for our orders to be taken, and there were delays in getting our food and drinks. The servers lacked attentiveness and were not proactive in addressing our needs. The overall service could definitely be improved.

In summary, this restaurant deserves a rating of 3.5 stars. The food quality was commendable, and the facility had a pleasant ambiance. However, the prices were slightly high, and the service was lacking. With some improvements in pricing and service, this restaurant could provide a better overall...