Marble Slab Creamery — Restaurant in New Braunfels

I’ve been coming to this location for many years. My wife and I have purchased many cakes, cookies, ice creams & have supported every fundraiser this location has had to offer. Unfortunately we have both come to the decision to no longer purchase cakes from this location anymore. Over the past 8 years we’ve purchased anywhere from 9-12 pan cakes alone(big family) and they’ve always been exceptionally beautiful cakes. However the past few cakes we’ve purchased have been decorated horribly. We don’t expect perfection but these cakes are just very subpar to what we used to receive. They look as if a very inexperienced employee has been decorating them. If the prices weren’t so high I wouldn’t mind paying regardless of how the decor looked, but that’s simply not the case! The little blonde girl Alexandria always took care of our orders and the sky was the limit with our ordering she made our own special version of Harley Quinn since it was copyright, Air Force and Navy appreciation cakes for our military background. Zoo themed cake with very realistic animals and many more! Wish all of these were still an option but sadly we know not to have high expectations anymore. Oh well! Off to a...

I have been getting Great American Cookie cakes for my children every year on their birthdays. Yesterday I purchased a cookie cake from this location and I have never been more satisfied! The young girl behind the counter was so helpful with my order and even made the cake right on the spot for me in a matter of minutes! She was so sweet and even offered me a complimentary drink & chocolate chip cookie while I waited. The cake had a simple Happy Birthday Tyler with a picture of my sons football jersey on it. She asked me what his favorite colors as well as his teams colors were and proceeded to make the cake with the ones I listed which is something I have never been asked before and have normally received only white and chocolate icing. Once finished she rang me up and with the purchase of my cake she included a $2.00 off coupon for my next cake along with 2 free cookie cards because I had told her I had two sons at home that absolutely love the cookies here. Overall the cake and the superior customer service here will definitely have me coming back again! Thank you Alexandria you did such an awesome job on my sons cake and you helped make his birthday so much...

“Frozen Majesty: A Love Letter to Local Dairy Royalty”

Nestled between Terry Black’s BBQ and Buttermilk Cafe lies a temple of frozen transcendence: The Creamery of Dreams, otherwise named Marble Slab Creamery.

From the moment you step inside, you’re greeted with a waft of waffle cone so seductive. The décor is whimsical, like Willy Wonka and Martha Stewart had a Pinterest baby, and the ice cream? Ah, the ice cream. Each scoop is a dairy-fueled sonnet composed by angels with culinary degrees.

The service? Impeccable. The scoop artist—nay, the Frozen Custard Connoisseur—handled my cone with the grace of a Michelin-starred ballet dancer. He offered me a sample of “Birthday Cake Cookies and Cream with Oreos which tasted like a toddler’s dream and a dentist’s nightmare. 5 stars.

This place doesn’t just serve ice cream. No, it curates a frozen experience that caresses the soul and lightly slaps the thighs. I left Marble Slab Creamery two scoops happier and three calories closer to nirvana.

Would I return? Only every day until I die. Or they run out of HomeMade Vanilla. Whichever comes first.

Rating: 47 out of 5 stars....