Costa Pizza Restaurant — Restaurant in New Haven

Used to really like Costa Pizza, but the quality of their food seems to have taken a turn for the worse. I ordered a small pizza (with mushrooms, pepperoni, and roasted tomatoes) a few weeks ago. The pizza itself left a weird aftertaste, and the "roasted" tomatoes I paid extra for were just thick slices of un-cooked tomatoes. This made it soggy and gross. I decided to give them one more try today and ordered spaghetti and meatballs. The sauce was watery and bland, the meatballs were tasteless, and it was really unsatisfying overall. The side salad was fine, but the small rolls that came along with it were horrible. They tasted like nothing, but they still somehow tasted bad. Wish I could get my money back, but the least I can do is not order food from them anymore. Think twice...

This place use to be my families go to spot for a late dinner option. At one point we thought the hot wings were THE BEST for a pizza place and the Meatball pizza was delicious. Our last late dinner order with them has changed our minds about even considering to order from here ever again. Our wings were not fried crispy as requested instead they were covered in feathers and looked as if they cooked them frozen and threw hot sauce on them.We ordered the 12 piece hot wings and could nibble on 2 (one for each of us). Surprisingly the pizza looked like they spread parmesan cheese all over it instead of mozzarella the cheese was crispy though the irony. The customer Service is down hill and the food is too. Just be cautious they have their good days but at...

Very Disappointed with them. I order with them all the time but After this experience not going back. I ordered 6pc buffalo wings and small Cheese pizza. I got home. Lived in wallingford. Wings have no sauce at all Bascially plain deep fried. I Called the store. The owner said come back and exchange but Unfortunately i lived in wallingford not driving another 25mins for 6pc wings. So he gave me credit. I went back again today and order 6pc wings again. Then he asked me for $5 dollar said already discount... When u give some credit it means free not discount! Then got home open the wings the sauce is only like 3 drops and half bowl of oil. Just look at the picture i posted. Not going back. Go to EST EST EST pizza. Theyre so...