Up Top Grill — Restaurant in New York

If I could give this place zero stars I would. I just ordered online and got curry goat with a rice and peas, with a side of Mac and cheese. I get my order and I see that I only got a plate of curry goat with no rice and peas and it was a small and i remember ordering a large. There is no way someone messed up my order this bad, I honestly feel like it was done purposely because it was an online order and I can only reach out to Uber to refund me the money for the other items I didn’t receive, I paid $36 for me to only get a small curry goat with no rice and peas and Mac and cheese. You guys need to add more cheese to the Mac and cheese. All you had to do was read what someone ordered and make it, I’m never...

Normally I love this restaurant small quaint authentic Jamaican food. The portion size is always reasonable. I travel all the way from Manhattan passing about 25 other Jamaican restaurants just for this one. Oxtails my favorite and most expensive on the menu so my expectations are always high. This Saturday I was highly disappointed, the spices were way off, not cooked long enough so they were a little tough. Dry not enough gravy to help it. I also brought shrimp fried rice and honey barbecue chicken that was a little better but not for me. Maybe I'm judging a little harshly but I couldn't get through my meal and neither did my husband....

Edit* 2025

Changed from A four star to three.

Food taste better than most of the other Jamaican restaurants in the area, wayyy better than golden crust on Allerton, (golden crust can't fail with beef patties though)

That's the edge they hold over all the others. (Was)

Prices are poised to get out of control very soon.

They are also getting stingy with their sharing of food, they might become another Lash.

Every now and then the food is a miss. 3 out of 5 for inconsistency...