First Watch — Restaurant in Newark

We had a very poor experience at First Watch Newark on March 1, 2025. We were a party of 11 and joined the waitlist at 11:00, in which it said it would be a 15-20 min wait. We then arrived and checked in at the restaurant at 11:30, and were told it would be an additional 20 minute wait. I know wait times aren’t always accurate so I understood. After 30 minutes, we approached the host asking how much longer and he said another 20 minutes. I informed him that we joined the waitlist an hour ago and it was way past the estimated wait time at that point. The host told me they were waiting for a few tables next to each other to open up. But that wasn’t happening because we saw a few different tables near each other open up while we waited, and they were always sat with another group. Another person in our party then approached the host and questioned why it was taking so long. The same host then told this person in our party that they “don’t necessarily hold tables for large parties because then they can’t seat other guests.” We noticed a few more tables available next to each other, but the host then sat other people there. At this point it was 12:22 when a manager approached us and said he could seat us. I said “where?” because at this point there weren’t any tables near each other. He said “party of 3 right?” And we said no….party of 11. He scrambled to move tables together, which was appreciated, but we didn’t sit down until 12:32. 1 hour and 32 minutes after joining the waitlist (with an original wait time of 15-20 min). This was unacceptable, and we felt extremely dismissed by the host who told us “they won’t hold tables for a large party” if it means they can seat a smaller party instead. It was shocking for him to say this. Additionally, the manager never apologized. When we finally sat down, the waitress informed us there wouldn’t be any additional issues (I was hopeful of this because we were celebrating my cousin’s birthday and our experience was already tarnished). I ordered a farmhouse hash. My hash came out WITHOUT potatoes. A potato hash without potatoes. I gave the food back to the food runner and then the waitress came over and said it was her fault because she rang it in wrong. I’m not sure how you accidentally ring in “no potatoes” instead of “extra well potatoes” like I asked for. The server told me to keep the rest of my entree and then brought back a plate of potatoes that weren’t cooked how I asked (I asked for well done). Finally she brought over semi-well done potatoes, but at this point the rest of my entree was completely cold. Overall, this dining experience was incredibly disappointing. A party of 11 brings in a lot of money, and I felt like we were treated poorly by the host and the food experience wasn’t great either. We were here to celebrate my cousin’s birthday, and I feel like it was ruined. I will not be returning.

Also I contacted First Watch about this a week ago and never heard back. Not...

A consistently good chain in a pretty busy area. You don’t make reservations here, you call to put your name on the list and get a rough wait time. Note, though, that when you get to the restaurant, you’re checking in from the list, not being seated. We arrived 15 minutes after being told there was a 15 minute wait after checking in. Still, once your name is up, you’re seated and served quickly. This is a tight ship: your order is taken fast and you get coffee right away. Our food came quickly as well!

This place is BUSY: expect it to be loud and crowded, especially on a weekend! Parking can be a little tough for that reason.

Finally, the food: my whole party was very pleased. The fall specials were delightful! My grandma was especially happy that her eggs were cooked exactly the way she requested. As a vegan, my main option here is the superfoods plate with chia seed pudding and almond butter toast. I’ve had this every time I’ve been here and it’s consistently good and filling. The juices are great as well. The iced coffee is far more sweet and milky than it is coffee so keep that in mind. Overall great service and good food but be...

First Watch is a great spot for a healthy and delicious breakfast or brunch. The menu features a wide variety of fresh and flavorful options, from omelets and pancakes to salads and smoothies. While the food is definitely on the pricier side, the quality is top-notch. Pros: Fresh, high-quality ingredients: The food is made with fresh, locally sourced ingredients, which you can taste in every bite. Creative and flavorful dishes: The menu is full of unique and delicious combinations, like the Avocado Toast with smoked salmon or the Acai Berry Bowl. Pleasant atmosphere: The restaurant has a bright and airy atmosphere, making it a great place to relax and enjoy your meal. Cons: Price: The food can be a bit pricey, especially compared to other breakfast options in the area. Limited menu: While the menu is diverse, it can be a bit limited if you're looking for something specific. Overall: If you're looking for a delicious and healthy breakfast or brunch experience, First Watch is a great option. The food is fresh, flavorful, and well-presented, although it can be...