Newark Deli & Bagels — Restaurant in Newark

Custom experience was terrible, I’m a sever and so is my girlfriend. We understand mistakes and would typically never write a review. My girlfriend has an egg allergy and I told them when I ordered, when I went home her bagel had egg on it, she called and very nicely explained to them the mix up. They said if we come back we can pick up another bagel (never mentioned we have to bring the bagel back). She lives right down the street so I walked back. When I came for pick up they said I needed the old bagel, I told them I threw it out because we couldn’t eat it and they replied “how do I know you didn’t eat it”. So I called my girlfriend and she brought the bagel from the trash to the store. They finally she exchanged the bagel after 3 trips back to the store. The counter girl who took our order was very nice and apologetic, but the manger (at least who I think is) was extremely rude, unprofessional, and unapologetic about her order and not exchanging it after they messed u and not to mention an allergy issue that we told...

I believe they have the best everything bagels around, hands down. Honestly, they have never been known for good service, but their far superior bagels has kept me coming back for years. But I don't know if I can anymore. It is unbelievable how frequently they get my order wrong. Their success rate is under 50% as of late... Usually putting my breakfast sandwich on a different bagel from what I ordered. I always call in my order and thought maybe I am not communicating it properly.. I always get a whole wheat everything, but too often they put it on a plain whole wheat bagel. This last time I asked them to repeat it back to me. They did, and it was accurate. I get home, and two sandwiches are on whole wheat BREAD 😡. With the prices increasing as much as they have, I can no longer justify spending that much knowing I have a better chance of getting a sandwich I did NOT order than what I did. After 25 years of frequenting Newark Bagel, I am...

Newark Deli and Bagels has been my favorite since my undergrad years at UDell. Every Saturday morning, like clockwork, I’d grab breakfast there — and all these years later, not much has changed! Whether I’m driving up to Jersey with my husband or visiting with friends, we always make a stop.

My go-to is the Taylor ham, egg, and cheese on a multigrain bagel — scooped out and extra toasted — and it hits the spot every single time. The bagels are perfectly crisp, chewy, and flavorful. Honestly, even in New Jersey (yes, Jersey), the bagels don’t hold a candle to the ones here. And now that I live in Charlotte, NC, I miss this place even more — there’s just nothing like Newark Deli and Bagels down south.

Delicious, consistent, and full of good memories. A true gem that...