Johnny's New York Style Pizza — Restaurant in Peachtree City

Years of passing by this spot and we decided to try it for my girls 3rd birthday brunch. Prior to our arrival I stopped by to check out this spot. I was greeted by someone who seemed like an owner haha. I explained a party of 10 would be here later. He graciously gave my toddler some quarters for the fun machines. I was totally blown away by his graciousness. We arrived with our group later that day. Our table was already setup and we were seated right away. Our drink order was taken quickly as well as our appetizer order. Everything was well paced and we didn’t feel rushed as we ordered our food shortly thereafter. Good heavens the garlic knots were top notch as they arrived relatively quickly at our table. The birthday girl ate several of them and she never eats ANYTHING new y’all. Fried pickles were hot and delicious. Our pizza orders arrived hot! My favorite is definitely the bbq chicken. Those 4 pizzas didn’t stand a chance lol. I checked out the bathrooms and they were clean except for some TP on the floor it just needed tidying. Clean wholesome place with just some dang good food. Service was impeccable, drinks stayed refilled and the food has me craving to go back soon.

Check out Johnnys pizza y’all. A true family spot with a mini arcade and a wholesome experience.

Food: 5 Cleanliness: 4.5 bathrooms needed tidying Price: As was expected = 9 people (4 medium pizzas, 3 appetizers, 3/4 salads I can’t remember & 7 drinks + 2 waters) $147.00

Money spent at the arcade: 6.50 😂 we couldn’t say no to the birthday girl

WE WILL BE BACK Thank you...

Stay away!!! This used to be a great pizza place as my family and I would go at least 3-4 times a month. But stay way unless you want to be served rotten, spoiled food. We order two pizzas , one plain and one with some toppings. When they came out the cheese was pooled up like queso cheese. It looked and smelled awful. I told the waitress and she even agreed. (No idea why they would even bring it out) then they remade both pies and they had the same issue. Clearly the cheese had spoiled or was contaminated. It was gross. I sent them back and then it was brought back out to me. The server told me the manager said this is how their pizzas are made. I was beyond shocked and appalled. That he would send the waitress back out with the in-edible food, he didn’t even have the courtesy or decency to come out and talk to me. Whatever batch of cheese they were using at this particular time went bad. Clearly management in this place thinks it’s OK to serve, spoiled and rotten food to its customers. I will never ever come back to this place and I strongly recommend the same to...

Went Thursday, ordered $40 worth of food. Food is great, don't care for the garlic parmesan wings tho the chicken tasted fresh and was cooked well. Absolutely loved the firecracker shrimp.!! Went back Saturday night before work, gave myself 40 minutes. It's only about 7 minutes from work. They were kind of crowded, a little close to closing ( 830pm). Wanted those shrimp and small salad. One woman on phone trying to fix a problem with an order, I another running tables, she says someone will be right with you. No prob.after bout 8/10 minutes, problem solved. She offers problem order a free drink for the trouble, cool. Then she takes two call in orders and didn't even look my way. Another young lady comes up front and starts to put beer bottles in the cooler and begins talking to the lady on the phone. Still, no one even looks at me. So I leave and won't be returning. All three of my grown children work food service. Two chefs and a grower, they say this is unacceptable. I'm sure my few dollars won't harm your bottom...