PrimoHoagies — Restaurant in Rockaway Township

Update 1/3/25

Sadly there appears to be a new owner and new workers here. None of the people that I used to see here weekly are here anymore. Sadly, it’s very slow service. Only one person working to make bread, sandwiches, answer phone, take orders. All of the meat in this cheesesteak sandwich is burnt. Trying to pull out all of the charred hard pieces. Yum. (I order no cheese). The area where sandwiches are made was pretty messy. Disappointing.

———- prior review I love the sandwiches here. First off, the staff is very friendly - I’ve always had nice, attentive service here and most importantly, they’ve never messed up my order, not a single time and I usually come in at least once a week.

Second, it’s always very clean. The bathrooms are clean and where they make the sandwiches is clean. As someone who is grossed out by tuna fish or by condiments like mayo and mustard, it’s important to me that my plain roast beef sub isn’t dragged across a messy prep area. Here, the meat is sliced to order (the roast beef is perfectly cooked, sliced thin and delicious) put onto the freshly baked roll and then wrapped up (I usually request no cutting of the sandwich due to my above fears of knives that have touched other items I have an aversion to).

This is the only place I will get sandwiches. I like the steak sandwich (no cheese), and plain roast beef with nothing except the spices. Easy order, hah. Our kids like the meatball and chicken parm.

Very easy to order either by phone, online, at a kiosk or with a worker. I prefer ordering from one of the friendly staff since they are quicker and I know it will be right.

My only suggestion would be if there is any way in the future to offer a gluten free roll option for my wife. I know they offer the sandwich in a bowl option but she prefers a normal sandwich on GF roll/bread. So if that’s ever a possibility, my order will increase with an extra sandwich.

Thanks for being such...

Very disappointed with the service today. I called to place an order for some subs, and the young lady answered the phone, at first I could not understand what she was saying, and asked for a BLT on a long roll. She then proceeded to tell me that they do not make this sandwiches, and I was the third or fourth person to ask for such. I could not get a word in edge wise as she continued to talk with the person working with her about my asking for a BLT. I attempted to interrupt her as she and the worker laughed about it but was further interrupted by her continued laughing. As I attempted to tell her about the rest of the order she kept talking to the other worker so I hung up and gave my business to someone else. How unprofessional can these people be? The owner of the establishment should really watch to see how his business is being run . If you don’t have something say so and move on. Don’t disrespect people by laughing and carrying on another...

Lots of options from old school Italians to cheesesteaks and chicken cutlets. I recommend an original Italian. It was loaded with Meat and toppings. I can’t say I was disappointed with the chicken cutlet as I didn’t have high hopes for franchise chicken cutlet but then again I’ve also had some of the best in Jersey but this was not good. It was basically a large soggy chicken nugget. The breading was mush and there was no seasoning. Toppings were good I got it with prosciutto , provolone , roasted red peppers and balsamic. It sounded good but the soggy chicken held it back. The bruschetta and pesto were good on my other sandwich but same soggy chicken .Once again they have lots of options and even sides of macaroni salad , potato salad, mozzarella balls etc… I might go back in a pinch if I had no other option and probably stick with an original Italian. lots of seating , clean ,...