Spicoli's Toasted Subs — Restaurant in Salina

Great food, highly recommend. Staff are courteous and helpful.

I’m usually so picky about sandwiches and this place has made me realize maybe I’ve been missing out on great food with that attitude. I’ve tried to explore the menu, but there is something so right about both the G-Man and the Judge that one of those is what I usually get. I also appreciate the assortment of mustards available here. Would be obsessed with a hot sauce on the table, too, but mustard will do.

They have a loyalty sandwich punch card, but it’s not always offered. Ask for it if you’re into that kind of thing.

I try to come during “down” times, but I’ve seen this place packed and staff moving fast between tables and the kitchen. I’ve had to wait a bit for a pick up order during the lunch rush, and that’s normal and fine. Good to see a place so well liked that it’s busy!

The space is not dripping in light, which might be why it feels cooler in there coming in off the street (great in the summer). Sort of like a den. Not so dark that you’ll trip on something, there’s plenty of lighting, it’s just a darker-lit vibe. If you’re averse to eating in low lighting, make sure to grab a table by the large window in front.

TVs at the bar have various channels on with subtitles and no sound. Music is always on. Walls are decorated with an assortment of tchotchkes big and small, including a very endearing deer head over the window dining area.

tl;dr: Great food. Kind people. Den vibes....

1st. It was 2:15pm Only one table to sit at, 11 dirty tables, 5 people at the bar full & 2 other tables of 4.... Nobody said hi. Nobody bothered to tell us that we have to go up to the bar to order, so we sat there for 20 min... watching... The bartender cash out 9 tables & go back to ask the kitchen "how much longer " for a couple that was at the bar.... the Manager/kitchen lady was suddenly yelling the bartender for not helping her in the kitchen. Although there was a lady who was working with her in the kitchen. the only person who WAS working on food was the dishwasher lady FYI. & Kitchen lady was extremely unprofessional she the came into thebar area, yelling that tickets take 45 min & THAT was normal... we will not be back because she was ridiculous... Food, Not good at all. I didn't know a French dip had grilled onions, but mine did... my husband had a ditch weed, he thought it was OK. Would not order it twice tho. Upon checking out after watching this entire fiasco unfold....Kitchen manager came out again, yelling about knowing Russell better than a customer, kicked them out BEFORE they got there order they had been waiting for over 50 min for... they never yelled back... I think she had recorded the kitchen lady's behavior.

Sad...

Great sandwiches! Excellent service! This great little sandwich shop accommodated a group of 20 women and 5 little girls without hesitation. We were given tables in the neighboring business/spillover room and provided with lots of space to spread out socialize and enjoy our meals together as well as room for the little ones to run around without bothering anyone. The staff was super helpful and friendly very professional and kind. The food was really good too and cost wise was less than something you’d pay for at a chain sandwich shop. I had the Caprese salad as a side and it was delicious…highly recommend! There was not one person in our group who did not finish their meal. Kudos to this place for finding us space and delivering a good meal quickly! Highly recommend...