5 stars for the bagels -- including their breakfast bagel sandwiches with eggs -- but 3 stars for the ambiance. So I average that to get a 4.
The good: the bagels are made fresh and are soft and tasty. The day old ones are a great deal. I've been getting their breakfast sandwiches for two decades and they are great ... while also affordable. Though as somebody else mentioned, microwaving their pre-made egg mix in Tupperware definitely doesn't impress.
The bad: the store is honestly falling apart. The bathroom literally is. They've put zero effort into updating anything in the 20+ years I've been coming here and it's getting just sad. I get it for a while (save costs to keep prices affordable), but it's time for a major refresh to bring the place into the 21st century. I believe it's really holding them back from a significant increase...
Read moreTheir lox sandwich is pretty good and tends to be on the bigger side as their lox portion feels generous. The place is spacious but they only have a couple tables inside, I think they have some tables in the back too though. It is amazing how the store front blends in if you don't pay attention, I went past a few times while I meant...
Read moreAbsolutely delicious!! I took a bite before taking a picture. The bread tasted so so fresh, cream cheese was locally sourced from a James Dairy Farm, and there were so many veggies in the smear. You can tell a difference from Holey Bagel that this place has fresher...
Read more