Went back today (6 months later see initial review below) and was completely disappointed. I've changed my review from 5 stars to 1 star. I understand that this was the last day before the store closed for vacation, but the Schiacciata Siciliana that we ordered to go was inedible. Barely any mozzarella and the main piece of eggplant was completely skin. Even the bread although crispy on top, the bottom (which should have been the same) was rubbery (all for $18). I was involved in the restaurant industry before retiring and I rarely give bad reviews because I know how difficult it is to always be consistent -- but this was totally unacceptable.
Initial Review 6 months ago: This is the real deal. Cappuccino & cornetto for breakfast. Schiacciatta (panini) for lunch. So amazing. Can’t...
Read moreStopped in last night right before they closed and the owner, Massimo was incredible! He explained everything on his menu, let me test a few things out and I ended up leaving with 3 new favorite foods! Everything they make is in-house with Sicilian ingredients. The pizza is like none you've ever had before with dough so delicate it melts in your mouth! I tried 2 different Aracini balls and they were so delicious! The one thing that blew my taste buds out of the water was the Cremino di Caffe....it's this creamy espresso drink that was incredible! I will be returning DAILY for that! Also the Granita di Limone (think Limoncello Icee) was also refreshing and delicious!! I can't wait to explore more of this menu. WOO HOO Sarasota has a REAL...
Read moreThe man running the front was super friendly and helped us pick out a few things because this was our first time here. The food was amazing. The sandwich was the best I have had in such a long time. Delicious bread and quality meats and cheeses. The attention to detail he took while making the sandwich was definitely noticed. The Olive oil used to dress the salad leaves was delicious. We had a ragu arancini which was also so flavorful and well done. We also had a ham and cheese calzone and that was amazing too. We are pretty sure all the other patrons at the time were Italian and that’s saying something if all the local Italians are there. Can’t wait to go back....
Read more