Silverton Café — Restaurant in Silverton

Just dined on a few takeout items from here tonight. Had the Reuben, chicken fingers, wings, and a pep calzone. Reuben tasted good, calzone was a straightforward good calzone. The wings were decent bar wings. The chicken fingers left a little to be desired. The reason I went from 3 to 2 stars was the key lime pie—it was 100% a cheesecake with maybe a little bit of lime flavor, but barely any. It felt misleading after eating it. Decent place, but just call something what it is 🤷‍♂️. Also, in fairness, Cincinnati is becoming a place with GREAT food. So this 2 would probably be a three in places with not many choices (even with the key lime pie situation).

I will try more menu items before making a final call, but this experience was...

So i figured chicken tenders were a safe bet. I was wrong. Burnt beyond edible. More like chicken jerky. Nothing tender about it. The cook blamed the oil. Ive worked in restaurants. It was not just dirty oil. My wife ordered a double decker turkey sandwich with a side of mayo. 1 layer had turkey and tomato. Comically the second layer had lettuce. Yup just lettuce. So nothing about the simple concept of "double" was an actuality. Oh and no surprises but no side of mayo. Lmao. IDIOTS. DONT WASTE YOUR MONEY. 🖓✌ lol talked to the cook and that's how they are "trained" to make a double decker. Lmao. wow i wonder what a triple...

This was my first time to Silverton Cafe. Went to see the band Deja Vu play, they were excellent! As soon as our waitress came up to the table you can tell she was not going to excel in this career. She was very friendly but not made to do this line of work. We finally had to ask another server if she would please take our table, which she graciously did. Had the mozzarella sticks as an appetizer, they were very good. Had the ham and cheese with fries to eat. It was very good, but small and short on ham in my opinion. Pictures of beer are $12.50 each and most beer by the glass is $3.75 each. I...